We need to make a clear distinction about being honest about P411 the platform and what they communicate to clients/ providers vs. being honest about some of the people on P411. If being honest is considered bashing, then we clearly have different thoughts on the value of being honest about something and being transparent about what the platform is communicating to one half of their user base.
Since you are discussing this from your POV, please remember you are the client. Based on your post history you feel as though P411 is all that is and have issues with "over the top screening" which is fair. And of course I'm sure you haven't had any issues because 1) you started on P411 when it was truly the "thing" to have to be verified and racked up a substantial amount of "okays" and 2) with a history as long as yours, I'm sure most providers feel confident with that. However, with time things evolve. Providers have been told P411 is one thing, clients another. In addition, P411 literally tells us to screen more so I think your issue should be with P411 because I'm not bashing in any way, shape, or form.
Now, some of the people on P411 are truly bad apples. Point. Blank. Period. This isn't me bashing P411 or the clients, it just is what it is. There are other ways to screen P411 clients outside of P411. All I'm saying is based off of my data over the past 8 weeks, I have seen an uptick in clients reaching out via P411 who are also blacklisted for things such as shorting the rate, NCNS, not paying cancellation fees, stealthing, pushing boundaries (like trying to get anal), lack of basic hygiene, overstaying, multiple people sharing the same P411 account, etc. Now anyone could argue that could be the case with anyone, but I find it intriguing that P411 (and sometimes P411/TER) users preach about P411 but are usually the ones heavily blacklisted.
Also, this idea that P411 has never been infiltrated is far fetched and has not been debunked. Once again, providers have means to communicate with one another and our own back channels. Even if there doesn't appear to be a strong community in a city, we touch base with one another if we know something is up. There have been stings in other cities where LE had access to a client accounts and were able to bust providers.
Again, P411 is great in theory; however in practice it has its flaws yet I still use it. But as I said before, if being honest about a platform (a business) is considered bashing, then it begs the question: why are you here?