Good question - I'm either a romantic or a fool or no doubt some of both, but for my ATF (we celebrated Christmas late last week) I go her a blouse from Thomas Pink, another from Burberry, an elegant yet comfy at-home nightshirt, a set of top and bottom nightwear from Agent Provocateur for other ocassions, and a big bowl of candy that, oh, also had 5 gift cards in it, one each from Victoria's Secret, Sephora, J. Crew (one of er favorite places), an art supply store (she's an artist), and tongue-in-cheek even one from Bed Bath & Beyond (hey everybody needs new towels and dishes once in a while, right?). Oh, and the usual gift. Hey, she's my ATF, I want to see her get where she wants to get, and enjoy the journey along the way 
Posted By: foreroticreview
So the hobby was new to me this year, from randomly calling numbers on Back Page in January and getting ripped off on a nice, regular basis to finding TER eventually and coming to the fascinating realization that I, he of the genre middle-aged-male-homosapien, can actually have sex with exceptionally beautiful and intimate young women. Ya it still makes me giddy as a schoolgirl, so what?

This now begs the question of just what the hell am I supposed to get an ATF for Christmas? To wit, I already pay her 150% of her going rate and have done so since our first date (just left the difference in the soap dish in the bathroom that 1st date). I want her to understand she is not not my favorite provider, but my lover and 1st true mistress. So cash seems not only redundant but way too impersonal. Gift cards? Kinda my calling card with these ladies anyway. Both of my ATFs travel to DC, so there is always some kind of gift card in the envelope for some kind of comfort item - national pizza chain so they can call in comfort food, music downloads, etc. So again, that just seems like something she would be getting from me anyway.
Top shelf lingerie? A wonderful idea for sure but who really benefits from that one? It is like when Ralph Cramdon bought Alice a new bowling ball for her birthday and had it pre-drilled to fit his fingers. Ya, like that.
And yes I asked her what she wants/needs. Her response was true to her nature, she is as unselfish out of the bedroom as is she in the bedroom. A simple "I love surprises, surprise me!" was the response when she knew she could have asked for the moon.
So anything creative out there guys? Or better yet, ladies, anything that you truly enjoyed receiving from a customer?
Thanks in advance.