How do people feel about reviews that are good but by a reviewer with only 1 review.

In the case I link to below the provider has 3 reviews all by reviewers with 1 to 3 reviews.  In the case of the person with 3 reviews they review the other girl in the ad.

Makes me suspicious...  Or am I being paranoid?

Suspicion seems MORE than in order, LE.

I would preceed with cautious. Two first time reviewers and one reviewer with three. Hopefully not from the same agencies. I would give it some thought before I leap.

For DC Companions (exact phrase) and you will find several posts. One from Jeop which I have provided a link to.

Gut instinct says stay away. The reviews are too similar. All the reviews are short. Two of them end in similar fashion with the same line...Move on

Wise to be cautious. The reviews of Amanda are suspicious in that they are one shot reviews primarily. But then again everyone starts somewhere. Maybe some guys started with her. But Lindsay Love is well thought of and if Selam works with her she's probably okay. What is not clear however is how Slema came to tem up with Amanda and whether or not she's still on good terms with Lindsay.  Maybe Lola/Selma is starting something new? Maybe Amanda is running things? Maybe everything is fine. But it is worth a little more investigation.

The responses to your questions all seem  worthwhile...the advantage of TER experience-based opinions. For what it's worth, a highly respected provider once told me to be very careful about reviews, selecting those providers who were well reviewed over an extended period of time...and to be very cautious about a series of single reviewers. It makes good common sense for those of us who are less adventuresome in the pursuit, particular, and want more certainty for a pleasurable outcome. However, I do appreciate the efforts of all the intrepid explorers out there.

Selma and Cassandra are well-known, lots of reviews from their time at TGND.  I have reported to TER some other, similar situations (such as one where one woman had one review, the reviewer had done two reviews, the other woman had two reviews, and "different" reviewers used exactly the same words for the two women) where there was no previous history, but the reviews are still up there.

I woudl agree with you. If a lady have a number of reviews that are above average form people that have very few review..caution flag is raised.

I would not think it would be LE.

I don't want to share publicly.

If it doesn't feel right move on don't take the chance. There are plenty of provider with lots of reviews