resources is because in many part of the world people are starving or live in poverty due to misguided government policies (South America), religious intolerance and suppression of women’s right (Central and South Asia, Middle East) , Authoritarian and Totalitarian rules (Cuba, North Korea, Ukraine, etc.), ethnic hatreds and war (Balkans, sub-Sahara Africa), and vast corruption.
I am no economist but I will try to tackle some of the underlying premises of over consumption by US.
1. Water – most water resources are not transferable except within the nearby geographic area. There is no weather altering machines invented yet. Within the North American continent which US resides, there are only 3 countries, Canada, US and Mexico. Canada is not as economically vibrant as US and has less industrial output and farming activities, hence the lesser per capita consumption. Mexico is a dry country and has a poor economy. One can claim that the southwestern part of US takes a lot of the output from the Colorado River and gave less to their Mexican counterpart. However, the water source is originated from the US and it is hard to argue that we are depriving the Western part of Mexico their fair share. Since US are not taking away Africa and Asia’s water, I don’t believe the water consumption pattern of US affects most of the people in the world.
2. Food – US is a big food exporting country. Setting aside the use of energy in the production of food (energy will be dealt with later), it is nobody’s business how Americans feed themselves. We use our technology and manpower effectively. The only part of food production that affects other countries is fishing. However, the US rate of fish consumption is a lot less than Japan, Southeast Asia and many part of Western Europe. We don’t have the huge species depriving dragnets of fishing fleets like in Japan and Taiwan. There have been a number of moratoriums on fishing issued in Eastern US that were necessary but nonetheless devastating to the local fishing industry. As far as I remembered, only in a couple of cases that western European countries and Canada have considered moratoriums on fishing. I am not sure they have implemented one. The rest of the world is AWOL in this issue.
3. Energy (portable energy, mainly Oil and Gas) – US is a big consumer of oil and gas, no doubt at all. However, if one divide the oil and gas consumption percentage with that nation’s GDP, (unfortunately I don’t have the data nor the time to check it out), I don’t think the US will come off as bad as the 25% consumption, 5% population data. China is growing fast and their energy consumption has greatly increased. It will be interesting to compare the correlation of consumption of portable energy and GDP among US, India and China.
I think a lot of these talks of the evil of capitalism practiced in US ignore the importance of Happiness, Freedom and Opportunity. Unlike in many parts of the world including Western Europe, US is still a society that rewards ideas and hard work. We don’t have the ridiculous regulations and vast corruptions that stifled innovation and economic activities. We have much less class prejudices and subtle nativism compared to Japan, India, UK and Germany.
US scarified hundreds of thousands of lives to liberate Europe and Asia in 2 world wars in the last century. This country has defended the freedom of hundred of millions of people in Western Europe and South Korea with decades long military commitments and hundreds of billions of dollars and many young soldiers lives. We have opened up our economy to the world to help nations such as Japan, Singapore, Malaysia, South Korea and China to rebuild their economies. Thanks to the generosity of foreign student admission policy and the transfers of technologies, other countries have benefited greatly.
I, as a naturalized citizen, do indeed have a lot to be thankful for, especially to this the Greatest and most Generous country in the history of the world.
p.s. Sorry, Greywolf, I just can't resist the bait.
I still believe it is important to post counter arguments although they rarely change the other person’s mind.
-- Modified on 11/28/2002 10:07:27 AM