Though only a few years into TER and this world (and mutherfucking christ it beats Craigslist) I think I have figured out scoring.  I'll eat shit for it in the comments probably, but hell, it's a Sunday, I'm drunk, and I feel like preaching.  

besides anyone who PUI's is good in my book. lmao

Yeah

I've written only two reviews and both were such bad experiences I will probably never do it again.

i like how you roll in your summarization and totally agree.
Now, if all of us would actually give ratings; not based on your personal viewpoint, but on the actually definitions as they apply to the rest of the general population.
Rating a 9 or a 10, means they could be walk down a Victoria Secrets runway.
Rating a 8 is what it is, almost a model.
Rating a 5-7 (maybe an 8) is what you find at most strip clubs.
Ratings under 5 is what the rest of the population falls into. And still, there are a lot of gals that i'd consider to be a 5, attractive.
Now, just because you "like-em" a bit plump, or giant bolt-ons, or a big ass, or giant-tube-socks-tits, etc, etc....doesnt make her a 9 or a 10 to the general population. Not at all, she's a 9 or 10 in Your book. But she's not a model-material or once-in-a-lifetime. IF she were, she wouldn't be getting paid for sex. She's a 9 or 10 in your eyes, and thats totally fine. But the rating system here on TER should be what it generally believes to me to be, a real-world rating.  
I got a buddy who is thin as a rail, but he LOVES really, really fat girls(and i mean big girls). He thinks they are all 9's and 10's. And thats fine too, its his personal opinion. But his views are not those of the general public at all. Now, if i were to see one of his bigger girls, i would rate them a 2 or 3 , and so would the rest of the general public.
If i do a search here on TER for all gal's that have 9's & 10's, probably about 5% of them could walk the runway in Paris or in Milan, or walk down the runway for Victoria Secret's.  Also, there are even fewer gal's over the age of 30 that could be models regardless. Just cause she's got a shaved beaver, bolt-on's, and swallows, doesn't make her a 9 in looks either.
I understand that 'beauty is in the eye of the beholder', but if i'm the next guy to plunk down my cash to fuck someone based on her 'looks' ratings here on TER, by all those who gave these gal's those skewed/high ratings, i'm gonna pissed and as is the gal i'm standing in front of...when i take back my donation and give her $50 bucks for her time, and then i go get back in my car and leave.
So i wish guys would stop rating those so fricking high, just because the fuck and suck ya.  
Personally, in reviewing my own ratings from over the years, i'd lower 90% of the looks ratings down 2-3 points. I'd leave the other 10% where they are presently.

You are now the 25,000th poster to have observed something like this.

9 or 10 she looks better than her photos
8 or 9 she looks exactly like her photos
7 she look a little worse than her photos
6 her photos are very old
5 she might be the girl in the photo but sorely misrepresented
1-4 she is not the girl in the photo

this.  Is she still an 8-9

Deuces.

It's great to see you here beautiful! I hope the same for you!

You know I keep track of those things.

A simple change and can still be highly rated and no difference in opinion on what's my 7 is your 10.

Yes! Because you should not be seeing her in the first place unless you felt her photos were at least an 8!

9s are table stakes here.  Table.  Stakes.  

the huge number of women who don't show their face on the web?  How do we determine the difference between a 1 and a 10 in your system?

I think had you actually been the 25000th post on the topic, you may have gotten a year of free VIP plus a ride on the TER corporate jet (although I heard they got rid of the jet due to budget cuts), but as I mentioned to inicky you are shy by 631 posts.

even the term "model material" reflects a bias.
Sure models are very attractive - I'd be an idiot to say otherwise - but the stereotypical body-type and height of a model is NOT my ideal.

welcome back to you too Angela. Haven;t seen you here in a long time. Hope all is well.

Most every guy makes numerous judgment calls every day about whether or not a woman is attractive to him and how high on a pedestal to place her.  My brain has been honed over the years to such a very fine point that it takes a mere second to register whether I'm attracted or not.  Could give a crap less over someone else's assessment regards the looks of any woman.  Does the way she looks garner MY attention is the only criterion that is relevant.

That happened once to me and this was the result

Saj!~
I miss you!  

Miss chatting with you.