Like I'll see a provider with near consistent 10s in looks and then all of a sudden a reviewer dings this number because of a bad experience. Is it done out of spite?

meaning they should be judged independently with one have no bearing on the other.

Anyone who is really honest already knows that there are very few real 10's being reviewed here. However, I have seen some 10 appearance scores attached to 7's in performance over the years.

I had a couple of those.. You live and you learn that sometimes you can just "accommodate" things that are unsafe..obviously the only way get back at her is to tarnish the positive track record that we aim to have..

and then everyone else gives her a ten so each subsequent guy who is happy with her feels he has to give her a ten or hurt her feelings. Finally a guy who gets a so so session from her comes along and doesn't feel any obligation to continue the lie.

It's like Panthera said, there are very few real 10s out there, but there sure are a lot who get 10's in their reviews. Personally a TER 10 doesn't mean jack shit to me, which is a real disservice to the handful of real 10's out there whose scores are cheapened by "grade inflation"

Is ok in my book.  10's are hard to come by IMHO on looks simply because what is one guy's 10 in looks is another guy's 8 or 9.  It's taste, it's subjective.  Experiences of the negative sort make people picky too probably out of spite.  Myself I try to be honest, as to my own perceptions.  I have never seen a 9 or 10 provider yet, they may be out there, but I haven't seen one.  I've been with some 8 and 9 providers for service, but not looks.  As for once in a lifetime, 10.  Guess that only happens once in a lifetime....  I'm young yet.

Dear Keystone:
You are unequivocally correct. Looks are based on visual physical presentation and the total gestalt of the garments she would be wearing; Performance is how she executes behind closed doors and satisfies you while taking you to the hedonistic throes of passion.  Thus those should be the characteristics when judging the aforementioned categories.

and personality.  If you like the girl she can look even more lovely,  but that's just me.  

I agree. Fight grade inflation. Remember 5 is average. That means half the providers should get scores below 5.

I think a great performance...  if she rocs my world...  writing a review while the post coitus hormones are still running high probably bumps not only the performance but the looks numbers too.  How could it not?  I agree that IDEALLY they should be independent but REALISTICALLY they can never be.  
Disappointing looks can start a session out on the wrong foot & spoil the session no matter how hard she tries.  
A stunning beauty has an advantage score wise but many pretty girls take advantage and don't put the effort in...  or prefer to offer CBJ which will down grade their score.  

That's assuming equal number of girls who are below 5 get into this business.  

My over simplified answer is this... Pretty on the outside but ugly on the inside during a P4P date can result in a lower appearance score.

An unhappy client can "see" things differently just as a happy client can!



Steph

How low do the zinged numbers go? An 8, IMO, wouldn't mean the reviewer was doing anything out of spite. Just not his favorite type, she was having a bad day, or she didn't live up to the pics. 7 would be questionable, and lower would probably mean something unusual happened.

Dear Duplicitouslust,  

Dear Sexy and Sensational Steph:
I was just wondering when you look at the content of your reviews as well as the scores for performance and looks would you say that they're pretty consistent? Also I would imagine that you have varying degrees of compatibility with a lot of your friends, but did you have anything that would be attitudinal that would adversely effect your scores? Finally did you take this into account a little more when you were first embarking as a provider on whether a potential hobbyist or yourself would be a good mix? If so, could that be a reason for rejecting a date if you knew he was a known reviewer? Thanks and have a wonderful night Steph.

I've learned a lot since '05 and had to learn WAAAY more in 2013.

Dear Steph:
What did you identify that you were lacking in, in 2013? Also when did you realize that you were lacking in 2013?

There's a BIG gap in my reviews for a reason.

Beautiful on he inside almost always make a girl more attractive to me. If I'm enjoying my time (hobby or real) with a lady she becomes more attractive to me. In the same way, I've met ladies that I'm really attracted to at first site but after getting to know them they simply don't do it for me. I've never been able to separate the two.  

ask whomever did what you saw.

Some guys are just harder graders than others, so if some guy gives a 7/7 to a gal who has otherwise never gotten below an 8, you should click on that reviewer's history.  Often you'll find 7 or 8 is the highest he's ever given out.

So, consider the source.

Good looking women get treated better and same goes for men.