Write Review
1,979,010 Total Reviews 4,122 New Reviews
10,745 Users Online

Suggestion and Policy

How does that follow?
NoGreenBorderedEnvelope 1583 reads
posted
1 / 15
Turn off random moderation of posts when TER staffing is light.

For example, on weekends, and especially on holidays.  It can take a long time for moderated posts to be approved at such times.  IMO it would be better to focus scarce Admin resources on activities that are more important than reviewing randomly-moderated posts, and it would allow (non-moderated) TER members to better participate in discussions instead of having posts held up for a long time due to random moderation.

mrfisher 111 Reviews 203 reads
posted
2 / 15
How does that follow?


END OF MESSAGE

impposter 49 Reviews 383 reads
posted
3 / 15
I wonder what percentage of moderated posts are rejected?

More than 99% of my randomly moderated posts are posted after a delay.  Very annoying. Once in a while (2%?), I have to explain to a mod what I am posting and that it does not violate a rule.

justsauce16 4 Reviews 380 reads
posted
4 / 15
VIP

If you have VIP you should be exempt from random moderation and your posts should show up more or less instantly. The rules still apply obviously, and if you have VIP you should know the rules and follow them.

 
Also the lite-VIP that providers have should work similarly.

NoGreenBorderedEnvelope 374 reads
posted
5 / 15
Wrong.

Being VIP does not exempt members from random moderation.  I'm VIP and get hit by random moderation.

And although I know the rules and follow them, having VIP is no guarantee that someone knows the rules and follows them.  Anyone can get VIP by paying for it or acquiring VIP days in other ways.  

justsauce16 4 Reviews 378 reads
posted
6 / 15
Re: Wong.

Yes, I know, hence the "should be" bit of my message.

 
Obviously if you abuse it you get demoted back to the normal random moderation system. The idea is that if you have VIP, you're helping the board, and if you're getting moderated you can just buy VIP which further incentivises the service.

GaGambler 377 reads
posted
7 / 15
NO, actually you still don't get it

There is moderation and then there is random moderation and the two are quite different AND completely unrelated to your VIP status or lack thereof.

 
Random moderation is exactly that "Random" which means that everybody here will occasionally have a "random" post that gets kicked into the moderation queue. Breaking the rules doesn't get you randomly moderated, it means that ALL of your posts go into the moderation queue unless and until you are "unmoderated" by admin.

justsauce16 4 Reviews 379 reads
posted
8 / 15
Re: NO, actually you still didn't read.

Here is what I posted, because you didn't read it and you're off on a tangent.

>>VIP
>If you have VIP you should be exempt from random moderation and your posts should show up more or less instantly. >The rules still apply obviously, and if you have VIP you should know the rules and follow them.
>
>
>Also the lite-VIP that providers have should work similarly.

 
Note "should". I get how it works. I agree with NGBE, random moderation is a pain in the ass and could be better. I'm suggesting that if you have a VIP membership you shouldn't get randomly moderated. That way, when TER is sparsely staffed, your posts would still show up.

I realize that you can get sent to moderation jail for braking the rules, and I explicitly said that having VIP should not be a get-out-of-jail-free pass.

NoGreenBorderedEnvelope 363 reads
posted
9 / 15
I'm not in favor of that.

The only thing being VIP means is that you had enough money to pay for it, or you wrote a review (2 to start), or you got a problem report approved, or someone gifted VIP days to you.  It doesn't mean squat about someone's knowledge of TER posting rules and their ability to follow them.

Your idea IS like buying your way out of jail--random-moderation jail.  Except for within Monopoly games, I'm not a fan of that either (although I know it happens).

I see the point of random moderation.  I'd just like it to not be a roadblock to people participating in discussion threads when Admin is short-staffed.

justsauce16 4 Reviews 362 reads
posted
10 / 15
Re: I'm not in favor of that.

Right, and those are in the minority.  

We still have a report button recall, if someone tries something dumb, report them. You get VIP days for that too.

 
The fact is, TER has never, and will never be, adequately staffed. Simply turning off random moderation is a poor solution, but a solution all the same. Turning it off for VIP members at least makes sure some contribution to the board was made in exchange for the potential damage to the board.

NoGreenBorderedEnvelope 357 reads
posted
11 / 15
Re: I'm not in favor of that.

Not for sure. As I mentioned, VIP days can be gifted.  So some VIP members don't have to make any contribution to the board.

justsauce16 4 Reviews 371 reads
posted
12 / 15
Re: I'm not in favor of that.

In the sole instance of it being gifted VIP days they have indirectly contributed to the board, because someone, somewhere bought those days and they aren't using them personally...

 

Though, fair enough point, gifted VIP days excluded, problem solved.

NoGreenBorderedEnvelope 359 reads
posted
13 / 15
If you say so, Chief.


END OF MESSAGE

hiddenhills 143 Reviews 347 reads
posted
14 / 15
Is it over?


END OF MESSAGE

NoGreenBorderedEnvelope 367 reads
posted
15 / 15
I'm pretty sure it was...

... until you chimed in.  :D

Post Reply Back To Forum
Register Now!