Sca if mcnab,is a great qb, vick is unstoppable, how much are his jerseys worth, vick is mr nfl greatest comeback story in sports.i am rooting for eagles in,nfc but saints are tough brees game is sick so short how good he is, not my or kardashian favorite bush no heisman will be solid in playoffs, vikings I doubt,it,, packers good team but no superbowl team, in afc I think colts,ravens,steelers,jets, come get some afc championship drop a quarter, I have no clue, I hope my hero rex ryan will deliver, love my ny teams.

Your contention was that Vick was a better established NFL QB and I disagreed. I don't care that McNabb got benched in the final few minutes two weeks ago. As I said before, McNabb has led the Eagles to 5 NFC Championshiop games and 1 SuperBowl appearence. Michael Vick has won 2 playoff games. They played twice head to head in the playoffs, with McNabb's Eagles winning both times. Vick has never even thrown for 3,000 yards in a season; McNabb has done that 7 times.

Now to Vick's credit, he is FINALLY showing some accuracy this season with his passes. He has always been a superior athlete, able to make something out of nothing through his sheer running ability. This season, however, he has been able to make plays in the passing game...a significant improvement.    

Time will tell. If Vick leads the Eagles to a Super Bowl win, he will have something on McNabb. But really, to discredit Donovan McNabb as an upper eschelon NFL QB is ridiculous. He has had an excellent career.  

Well he is DOGGING me in the stats so if you think he is better you are BARKING up the wrong tree.

However in publis opinion McNabb vs Vick ...It's a TIE.