OH MY FUCKING GOD...... I gave an example of what CA and others want to do with the assets.
YET YOU STILL HAVE NOT REFUTED that the new SS tax proposal doesn't not increase the benefits that higher earners would get when they draw on SS. They would just PAY IN MORE and not RECIEVE any more in benefits. Which is against how the system is set up right now.
THAT IS THE FUCKING ISSUE THAT NEEDS TO BE ADDRESSED. Which makes this proposal FLAWED.
Which you keep ignoring. If this proposal or another one comes in and says to tax up to $1M but then the benefits received for those higher earners also increases.... then it would be a good proposal. The current ones just want to TAX without giving things back which is AGAINST HOW THE SYSTEM IS SET UP.
So a good proposal would be something like this:
Right now if you cap out at the highest income you get roughly:
$3000 a month for early retirement
$4100 a month for full retirement age
$5100 a month for post 70 years.
This is based roughly on taxing $184K at 6%..... 11K a year taxed every year you earn that much income.
NOW if they raise it to $1M you would have to pay roughly $60K a year in taxes every year you earn that much..... now they just need to raise the benefit for those people to something along the lines of....
$4000 a month early retirement
$5100 a month full
$6100 a month for post 70 years
That would mean a gain of $37K a year on those people who earn that amount. It would take about 4 years from one year of taxation for those people to use up that benefit. SO if someone makes $1M a year for 10 years (55-65 year old bracket).... that is $600K in taxes They retire at 65 (full retirement age) they would need to live another 50 years to get the "FULL" benefits of what they got taxed.
BUT THAT TYPE OF THING ISNT IN THE PROPOSAL!!!! They just want to increase the taxable income. Which is against how the system is set up.
MORE STATS for people who say TAX THE RICH...... you know that only 10% of our workers make over $130K a year. 5% make over $200K. 1% make over $500K Middle class is considered $36K to $200K depending on where you live.
There is only about 160M workers in the USA. These are things that TAX THE RICH never talk about. Why do you think no new tax proposals from many have safeguards in for middle class??? Once they get a "tax the rich" bill passed it opens the door to shift brackets down to different income levels.
Most REALISTS or people with a brain know you can't just TAX THE RICH to get us out of the deficit problem. You also need to CUT SPENDING. Which many on the left don't understand or want to.