Phoenix

Re: Different reviewers writing identical reviews on same provider?
WildBillHiCock 3 Reviews 1932 reads
posted
1 / 8

For VIP's - This has me puzzled and I don't know whether to start being suspicious of legitimacy of reviews. Was reading the reviews for "Haili" and the Sept review by tempeguy69 used almost all the same words and phrases as I had just read 5 minutes before... went back to check and sure enough the July review by llamastoday was virtually identical. And I also see where with other providers some of a girl's reviews are written with the same tone, length and flow (as an ex copy editor it's hard not to notice these things). Is it correct to conclude that either some reviewers copy and paste other reviews or some of the reviews aren't for real?

pinhunter 1 Reviews 1224 reads
posted
2 / 8

probably someone that just wanted the free membership to vip???

I talk all reviews with a grain of salt.

moebius8 2210 reads
posted
3 / 8

1 the profile usually has semidecent contact info
2 if the provider has lots of reviews you can spot the trends and at least get some idea of menu without asking the awkward questions.

other than that i wouldnt trust them unless you know the writer personally

tempeguy69 28 Reviews 893 reads
posted
4 / 8

Wild Bill, couple things wrong w/ your commentary. First, why the concern over two reviews for Haili since she's got 2 pages of reviews for you to rely on - are you just trying to whine for no apparent reason? Second, my review is not very similar to the one from 2 months prior.  Third, if you really want to judge how reliable I am, just look at all my other reviews - what's the likelihood that they're all fake?  Before you try to stir things us, use some common sense!

WildBillHiCock 3 Reviews 1052 reads
posted
5 / 8

Man, I knew this would happen. Amazing that you ask "why the concern" and think I'm "whining". All you had to do was simply read my post and compare the reviews. I wasn't looking to find any problems! When I recognized identical statements I became concerned. Obviously you didn't take that step which would have cleared things up. I won't accept criticism for merely pointing out FACTS and asking a QUESTION about them.

Here are some of the identical statements in each review (FACT). See if there might be cause for a QUESTION.

(1)
llamastoday:
I have seen her adds for a few weeks...

tempeguy69:
I have seen her adds for a few weeks...

(2)
llamastoday:
Once I got down the hall she was waiting with the door open and I was glad I came.

tempeguy69:
Once I got down the hall she was waiting with the door open and I was glad I came.

(3)
llamastoday:
she was wearing tight little pants and a tank top. We hugged and went right for the room.

tempeguy69:
she was wearing tight little pants and a tank top. We hugged and went right for the room.

(4)
llamastoday:
Not everyday I get to bang a 19yr old so I was very pleased.

tempeguy69:
Not everyday I get to bang a 19yr old so I was very pleased.

(5)
llamastoday:
If she figures out a little more GFE and less acting she will get 9 or 10.

tempeguy69:
If she figures out a little more GFE and less acting she will get 9 or 10.

More than coincidence?

AZartguy 85 Reviews 1664 reads
posted
6 / 8

I have noticed this same thing more than once from multiple reviewers - although the specific instances escape me (and I am not as motivated as Wild Bill to research), I accepted these instances as the other posters here did, and I wrote it off as phony reviewers trying for free VIP status that slipped through the TER's "QA" system  :  ;)

Anyway you provided some great support of your statement... I mean even down to the misspelling "ads" ("adds")... there can't be that many illiterates in the country  (alright, there is the current prez'dent, so I stand corrected).

By I am not judging - just taking my grain of salt when reading reviews.

moebius8 1064 reads
posted
7 / 8

what are the odds of both of them coming up with the exact same verbiage to describe what should have been a personal observation?

Its within the realm of possibility for her to hug the monger while wearing tight pants and a tanktop. ive seen her ads myself so ill let that go.
ill even go so far as to assume 19 yr old girls dont fall into their everyday experience.

#5 for me just screams either plagiarism or something less savory.

i would have to put a big fat busted on this review by tempeguy69.

if all evidence to the contrary is in fact the case then i would point the reviewer to this little gem at Purdue's wesite

2TM 1 Reviews 1184 reads
posted
8 / 8

For those of you that do notice this type of thing, i'd suggest submitting a problem report if you don't want to be subjected to the 'whining' of the people involved when they're caught.

I dont think the admin of this site advocates fraud but theres always going to be someone trying to cheat the system, no matter what board you're on.

Legit reviews should be taken with a grain of salt, but these reviews are a load of cr*p and shouldnt be taken at all.

You'll never raise the credibility level of the reviews in PHOENIX with complacency.  I travel to Chicago quite a bit and find their community is very intolerant of this kind of activity which means i save my fun money and wait until i'm in Chicago to play.

Judging by the # of Phoenix providers touring other parts of the country right now instead of working here, in what should be the busy season for Phoenix, I must not be the only one.

Register Now!