Sorry to beat this dead horse again, but I'm pissed! I submit a review and try and get the lady the 10 she deserves.  I follow the guidelines and she passed the criteria for a 10 - great performance (7), DFK (8), BBBJ (9), Two guys (10).  Here's the review: http://www.theeroticreview.com/reviews/showReview.asp?Review=658229&user=58155

Then I see reviews like this that get 10s: http://www.theeroticreview.com/reviews/showReview.asp?Review=658351&user=58155

What am I missing?

-- Modified on 10/3/2007 3:23:24 AM

Eric, this is par for TER, they are fast becoming a ho hum review board where rules are consistently broken by the so called "review board". I see reviews that could be recited at Sunday Mass and nobody would gasp in shock, and they are allowed to give 8's and 9's.
I only sumbitted 2 reviews in 07, basically for this reason. The reviews were submitted because the girls asked me to, and I was happy to help them out.

-- Modified on 10/3/2007 5:02:44 AM

I agree to a certain extent regarding review rules seemingly at times being overlooked.  However, I generally look past the numerical score and see the services provided.  If the review is kind of hum-drum but the services listed are up my alley, then I consider making an appointment based upon that.  I have seen more than a few reviews with an 8 or 9 performance rating, for example, where only a CBJ was offered.  Or someone who did everything from BBBJTCIM to Greek and only credited a 7.  That to me is a greater indicator, not the numerical rating.

Oh, I agree the extras offered only indicate what the potential score can be.  A 10, to me, needs to start with 7 points for great, non-mechanical, really-into-it, performance before the extras get added in.  

Knowing this, it is frustrating when you really think you've experienced a "10" and someone arbitrarily moves it down.  Then, when I see other reviews of about 4 sentences getting 10s, it's frustrating!

Eric, I can see your point, but if you just had a fuck that rates a 10, who gives a shit what someone else thinks about it?

Carlton,

Good point.  It's easy to get distracted by annoyances....life's too short for that....

geeeez

But, if you read the terms:

http://www.theeroticreview.com/info_policies/reviewFAQ.asp


"please try to save the 8 and 9 ranks for situations where out of the ordinary services are provided (i.e. Blow Job - without condom, Kissing with tongue, Really Bi, More than one guy). Each of these, beyond-the-call-of-duty talents count for one hard earned point. Of course, the 10 rating should be reserved for an experience that is really worth a million!"

Jamie; according to her profile:
1- Does not kiss with tongue
2- does not do anal
3- Is not Bi
4- does not do more than 1 guy at the same time

if such services are not on the menu for all( basically YMMV) then per policies and to be fair to others who provide those services she can not get a 10 in performance.