Be honest in a tactful way. The other posts here responding that if you can't say something nice, don't say anything at all are pure BS.
This is a review site, that you pay for. When I go on and look at a review and I see 9/9 or 10/9, I click on the reviewer's name and almost invariably, he has a list of reviews that are ALL 9s and 10s. What is the point????
I recently reentered the hobby after a 3 year absence, most of the reviewers that I trusted I'm not sure are still around. (christophertrac is one that is, however, glad to see he is still here!!!! great resource), fortunately I still remember how to navigate through the maze of white knight reviews.
The appearance reviews are what really get me. I know - different strokes for different folks - but again, if you are going to give everyone a 9 or a 10, what is the point? A 7 still means attractive, a 6 means nice.
I recently met with a girl who is pretty popular - probably because she is young, has a cute GND look and is VERY enthusiastic in performance. But the appearance ratings just threw me for a loop. Yes, she could be cute - but there were some very significant things adversely affecting her appearance. For anyone to throw out a 9 or 10 there - well that is just not being honest. I submitted my review and I gave a 6, and, honestly, in real life, that was being generous.
There is a way to be honest and still have tact. We pay money to this site for the honesty, if I want a white knight review I can just read the BP ad, lol.
Sorry, to be blunt, but DEMJay, write the review and say the pictures were "very dated, she was probably very attractive when she was younger," something like that.
-- Modified on 4/10/2015 2:00:02 PM