If you show up at a restaurant at which you have made a reservation and then decide you wish to leave, the restaurant hasn't lost anything at that point. They can easily seat someone else at the table intended for you, and never miss a beat. That is not the case with a provider. When you compare the analogy of ordering a dish, then simply deciding not to eat it, it is an apt comparison to walking out on a provider. The key element, whether we are talking about a restaurant or a provider, is the time/resources invested into seeing you as a client. There is a 'point of no return' past which, the provider simply cannot recoup the lost time and money by seeing someone else. A provider is not a restaurant where someone else is bound to walk through the door at the drop of a hat. Once you've shown up at the appointed time to see her, the ship has sailed on seeing someone else in your place. If you show up and decide to not go through with your session, she is plain and simply out the money she would have made. So basically, as I stated before, you in essence hold her solely responsible for the fact that the two of you didn't click. She becomes responsible because she has lost money. That is hardly fair to her.
So what it comes down to is, you ARE in fact paying her for her time, that is NOT just a quaint phrase thrown around to duck the legalities of this hobby. Not only have you not engaged her 'service' you have also prevented her from providing that service to anyone else.
If you think that one time here or one time there when a lady loses out on the revenue of a session doesn't matter, consider this. In the last week alone, I have had five no call no shows. Five of them. Now, that is unusually high, and I'm not certain of why, maybe its just a fluke. But in any given week, I can count on at least one or two no call no shows. I've only had one experience where a man showed up and left immediately, but the cause was justified - he was someone I had seen before, and he did indeed leave a partial donation, and returned to see me another time. The point I am making though, is welcome to our world. Every time we make an appointment to see someone, and that appointment doesn't happen, its not just a disappointment for us. Its not just an inconvenience. It costs us money. What you suggest is that simply walking away because the atmosphere just didn't seem right is an acceptable reason to deprive us of our income. Does that really seem fair to you?
Here is a compromise. If you show up for a session and the lady is not quite to your liking -not because it was a bait and switch, or because her pics are clearly 10 years old and 40 pounds lighter, but you simply don't click with her - instead of just leaving, stay long enough to find someone else to come and see her. Call one of your buddies, or call someone you don't particularly like, doesn't matter. Just take the time to find someone else to engage her services. She isn't out any money, and you didn't have to spend any of yours either. Sounds silly doesn't it? But its a fair solution. In the absence of that, half the donation assures that you don't engage in an experience you don't want to, but doesn't force her to bear the full responsibility for the fact that the chemistry just wasn't there for you.
Finally, regarding your experience with the provider who's attitude was apparently sub-par. That is WHY sites like TER were created. This discussion bears a striking resemblance, without the animosity, of the discussion started by Xi-lover. Her attitude sucked, but service was provided. Regardless of the details, or whether you chose to leave early or not - pay the donation. Use this site to screen out possible bad experiences before they happen, and also to warn other guys off before they go through the same experience.
When it comes down to it, if you do your homework, this discussion will most likely remain purely theoretical. And by the way, yes I have indeed given money back willingly. More than once actually, for different reasons.
*slydexia strikes again! Edited for spelling. (Its 3 am, what can I say?)
-- Modified on 5/2/2007 12:57:24 AM