...it's by a combination of personality and reviews, though the visuals override everything.
2) Even if I'm hooked, I am above all horny. Deferring horniness is not a skill of mine, or enjoyable. But it happens very occasionally, if hooked hard enough. The thing is, there are so many options. I've never seen so many strippers providing on the side. Thank you COVID. Twitter and Instagram bring more into the hobby every day. The temptation to move on is constant, especially if screening takes too long.
3) Rigid screening processes often don't work well and take significant, valuable, time, as providers are also aware. They are sterile and unattractive right when I am hoping to encounter a real person. It is the anti-viagra.
4) Instead, I usually work quickly with references & recommendations from friends (50%), or with known schedulers and agencies (30%). First option is a phone conversation. It's sometimes easy to tell immediately if it's going to work. Almost without exception, the beautiful smart local (underlined) women I've met are friends of friends. The other 20% is impetuosity.
5) The provider who takes the time to look at my first approach and makes an informed, quick decision to get back to me will get my business 9 out of 10 times, even when they need something else from me. If I run up against proforma screening, 9 times out of 10 I will drop out. Only twice in the last year have I followed through beyond that point.
A story. A provider asked me to fill in her screening requirements on a supposedly secure web form. Two days later she sent an email following up. At the bottom of the email was -All My Personal Info- as part of the email thread. I was furious, and pointed out that unencrypted emails are basically public info. She blew a fuse. I blew 2 fuses.
Well it wasn't my intention to get this far into the topic, but...
Lastly: The search for the ATF goes on, and I've come really close...

Usually my reviews are of newcomers and disasters. Looking back over the last year, 60% are first reviews, and there are surprisingly very few regrets among them. There are another maybe 10 people not reviewed. Four of them I am seeing regularly now. (This will be the year I go bankrupt, but it has been crazy fun)
Maybe this is the significant point: I did not screen this year -- other than with references, an email, and maybe a hobby phone number -- for any of them.
As the OP would say,
TL.DR - I don't often hang around to fill in screening forms.
[Paige, if you read this far, you could take the comprehensive screening info I emailed to you as a compliment. No one can call me rigid... except my intimate friends]