for the reason you state. Scores alone to not point to a fake reviewer unless you know he is being inconsistent in his own scoring. A lot of scoring is subjective, especially for looks since we all have our own preference as to what constitutes "perfect" looks. However, anyone who has seen a few dozen providers should generally the same views as to what makes for good service.
Then there are people like me who have our own scoring system. After reading reviews here for years, I found that most guys who use a 1-10 scoring system have a lot of inconsistencies from girl to girl. I have PM's some guys to inquire about specific scoring, and the majority cannot tell me quantitatively the difference between a 5 and a 6 or a 6 and a 7. This leads to over-scoring or underscoring the girls they see. I use only four grades, and I have been able to keep all of my scores consistent with each other. My scores mean the following . . . .
8 = Average
9 = Above-average
7 = Below-average
10 = Top 10% of all providers I have seen. (Subject to TER menu limitations on scoring for service)
Its easy for me to say where each girl I see belongs on this list. This way, I know that if I score a girl as Above-average with a 9, she performed just as well as any girl I gave a 9 to 4 or 5 years ago. There is no "bracket creep" up or down over the years.
So getting back to your point about fake reviews, I started noticing earlier this year that this guy often gets the details wrong in reviews of girls that I have personally seen as well. That's how I tell fake reviews, not from the scores. An example of what I mean is him stating in he narrative that a girl had beautiful blond hair, but in reality, the blond hair was only in her ad photos, and her hair has been black since she hit town. Another girl had a huge tattoo on her back that cannot be missed, even from 100 yards, but he was the first one to review her and set up her profile to say she has "no tattoos." They discrepancies run through a large portion of his review, and that's why I think a large number are fake, not because he only gives high scores.