Which would lead me to believe that he saw two different providers.

Saw a recent review for Tammy/Kelly on Backpage. Noticed she had a review from Sept. 2010 from draginballs stating he wouldn't recommend.

http://www.theeroticreview.com/reviews/show.asp?id=158090


Browsed a bit more and see a review for Dallas from Jan. 2011 also from draginballs. This time he highly recommends.

http://www.theeroticreview.com/reviews/show.asp?id=164988

If you click the backpage links, they both use the same pictures of the same girl. Hmm. You think he realized that when he made the second appointment?

Yes!