With a tip of my hat to Netnoy...
I was just thinking about posting a write up on my current WYP experience... The full post will come later. But I'll give you my preliminary feedback here wrt profiles.
I returned to WYP about 4 months ago, mainly just to kick the tires a bit and see if the site was as bad as I expected. I've now had 5 offers accepted. 2 were Pig Butcher or pay in advance scammers. 1 was a BSC (bat-shit-crazy) minor porn star who I suspect was just on there to GPS simps for her pimp. 1 was also a porn star, minus the crazy, who ended up joining me with my current Asian Porn Star SB for a Bucket List threesome. The last is a 21-year old ballerina who has agreed to a sugar arrangement after 3 dates and our 1st BCD is scheduled next week.
Compared to typical Seeking results (is there really any such thing as typical?) I am perhaps slightly over-performing. But the sample set of POT's and the short time frame (4 months) is probably too small to draw any conclusions.
Here's my profile approach and some other tips:
1. Since the site has, like Seeking, de-emphasized P4P, I toned down my profile text to focus only on dating and making friends. They have removed the checkbox for Sugaring, in the Dating Objectives section of profiles, but POT's can still mention it in profile text.
2. I added text about fun (non-BCD) activities like wine-tasting, live music, etc.
3. I use fewer pictures, and recommend you do not use any shirt-off pics or anything that comes off as "dirty old man."
About the "incentive" system:
1. I never offer more than $150 and try to stay closer to $100-$125 unless she is very hot, mentions something about "mutual" "sugar" or "FWB" in some way, and I have properly vetted her pics and profile info with zero yellow or red flags.
2. I won't make a 1st offer to any POT with a starting ask over $250. I've seen initial asks as high as $600 - which is laughable, considering we can hire an A-List pro for $600 any day of the week.
3. I always offer, or counter-offer, $50-$75 lower than the max I am willing to pay (regardless of her initial ask).
4. Most will counter my offer, and I will re-counter up to my max. Surprisingly, most (perhaps 80%) will accept my offer.
5. If accepted, spend site credits ASAP and swap contact info in the site message system. As with Seeking, no P4P or other sexual chat on site!
6. Try to schedule your date asap. The longer you wait, the greater the chance she will ghost you. The longer SHE keeps you waiting, the greater the chance she is a scammer or Pig Butcher.
7. Pick a date location that is not expensive. There is no reason to incur a $400 dinner bill just to find out she's not a good Sugar candidate.
I will make a comprehensive post sometime next month that reviews all of my practices and findings.
Life is good
The Cat