I don't expect any responses, just thought I would share something interesting, never happened to me before.  To place in context, BBFS.  Not would you do it.......kind of????

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TlsOyL0Z_po

Provider I’ve seen several times before got ready for cowgirl.  I said something like, “Uh, forgot the cover!”  She looked embarrassed and said something like, “Woops, sorry about that!” and grabbed the cover that was stashed under the pillow.

It's a little bit weird that you didnt feel her insides and thought she was just p2ping you. Also weird that you didn't feel the fc2. But you probably got caught up in the moment..  

I have lost some sensation as I have aged.  It did feel like I was inside, but her reviews suggested she did the stripper thing.    

Its hard to check out your review when you are posting with an alias AND you haven't provided her name.

been there where at the moment of entry the lady says . its ok go ahead,  i trust you .. or words to that effect.    very tough call, lets all be honest here.     BUT ..  if i understand the OP  it might have been the case of going BB without his realization, asking first etc.      there has to be a zero exception on BB where both parties are clear on what's about to happen and both clearly agree to it.     just as guys cant slip off the condom or distract the girl and just enter etc.  

This probably happens too often, based on my experience. Seems pretty dumb. I went along, once, many years ago. What followed was a period of abstinence and an extra $400 bill for thorough testing. I wasn't worried, and I think I did the responsible thing, in the end. The provider said, just eat some coconut oil, it's anti-viral! I'm sure that was some cutting-edge medical advice.

The whole "I got more of menu items because I look good/treat her well/etc" is mostly bs. Yes sometimes you will click and will get more service, but most of the time familiarity plays way more of a role than initial appearance.

TER ID: 122179

best to know your provider and if you do it you should get tested.

I have the great skill of confusing people.    

Either she is rather loose or your senses are dull if you mistook penetration for a  pole slide.  

1.  That was a fine example of the benefits of FC2, and of a woman with seriously advanced sexual entertainment skills.
2.  I have stopped things at the point of insertion to call for condom, yes.  
3.  Like another poster, I did let it happen once and went through the abstinence/testing consequences of that.  
4.  I make a habit now of handing her a condom before we get seriously started so that my intentions are clear.  
5.  I have been that flustered  by pleasure that I could have made the OP's mistakes too.  In fact, I try to get that high on her, that deeply into the pleasure.  So I try to stick to ladies who will honor my intentions, if/when I do get that way, and who will happily giggle at me over it.

I'd probably freak the fuck out!  

But since she took the whole thing on her own, limiting it to the tip would be moot.

Sorry to be the party pooper but just don't do it fellas.. don't let your hornball brain fuck you over, wear a condom.

It happened to me once when I was in a rather passionate and intense session with my long-since retired ATF.  I had gone down on her and had brought her to a couple of orgasms over about 10-15 minutes.  She reached down to pull my head up towards hers.  As I was surfacing, she grabbed the plumbing and inserted it.  I was just as caught up in the moment as she was and we did mish until completion, which didn't take too long.  At that moment, she was in control and I didn't object.   If I ever have another session as intense as that one, I can't guarantee I wouldn't do it again.