What makes a great bbbj to you,fellas ? Do you like wet and sloppy, or neat and clean? Is there a certain position that turns you on more then others? Does the effort count ? She tried her best but she just wasn't fellatio talented or maybe she was good but you could tell she wasn't into it? How important is a good bbbj, do you add or take away points depending on the performance of the bbbj alone?

My kinda guy

Sloppy and wet (isn't "neat and clean" sex kind of a contradiction in terms? lol), and lots of eye contact is a very welcome touch. I would rather have a slightly less technically skilled BJ with enthusiasm, I think, than "good but not into it."  Importance?  I guess I'd say it's not absolutely vital, but if it's good, it makes a big difference. In fact, at my age, sometimes the BJ *is* the main event as far as my side of the experience goes.

The blowjob is as much about technique as it is about attitude.

Agreed !

IMHO, it must include CIM, and a side of swallow, to be considered truly "great."

I think I would prefer that way too. Dessert that is, most certainly not a desert like the crazy bitch. lol

The best BJ's for me are a combination of techniques: lips, tongue, fingers, deep throat, slow, fast, light pressure, more pressure. I like it when it starts out light and teasing and then builds. The worst is just the head bobbing up and down. That's something a first-timer high school girl would do.  

There's nothing like lingering with your cock in her mouth for a minute or two after finishing, or have her continue to bring it to a slow ending.

Some girls give it to me better than others, and I couldn't tell you how. Except to say I like a BBJ/HJ combo, and I do have a particular way I like to receive the HJ part. Also, I like CIM.

Neither of your two reviewed providers gave you CIM or swallow, and you gave them 10's anyway, so WTF?

a light touch and lots of teasing.  Its all about the slow build up with a little edging that make the difference between greatness and mediocre.  

The way my ATF does it with minimal use of her hands. Alternating between deep throating, ball licking and me face-fucking.

That is none other than the lovely Ellie Kemper, who played Erin the receptionist in The Office, was a 21 Jump Street co-star and spent a summer as a Today show guest host.

The tongue can be the difference between a good BJ, and a great BJ.  

A strong, slow, and steady rubbing of the tongue against the glans (That's the under side of the tip.) feels just incredible to me.

Me, I like a lot of tongue up and down the glans (underside, that inch or two just below the head) as well as a little DT (no gagging, thats a turn off for me).  Sucking the head for a little intense action, especially a little heavy friction underneath and at the edge of the "helmet" for a while till I am squirming at the intensity followed by a "change up" of deep sloppy wet full shaft slurping for a while, then back to the intensity.  Edge me a little baby, get me to where you feel me pulsing precum then smooth it and change the rythmn.  Get me back to oh and ah instead of HOLY SHIT, then build me back up.  Its a bit of work, but sooo awesome when done right.  Then of course CIMNQNS for the 10.

and throw in some HJ while licking the balls!

There are so many variables and so many feel so good.  
Every now and then, a riding crop to the balls makes for a wonderful sensation.

very attractive lady enjoying an ice cream cone on a hot day, just licking the ice cream as it slowly melts.

Ms. Jordan always make sure that you pay attention to the frenulum so that you can induce semen during the course of the act.  Then you want to vary your speeds as you go up and down the shaft so that they will come to resolution in a reasonable amount of time.  Then for the some of us play with the scrotum as that contributes to an extremely pleasurable experience as well.

The best BBBJ is by a woman who LISTENS to my feedback (real time) and pays attention.

...honestly,dont think i've had a "bad" BBBJ-wet/sloppy is ok-but i love a tight/small mouth,that matches her pussy..69 is always my most fav position...2 me,there's nothing more exciting than a woman coming in my mouth...it makes "cock in pussy" sex,afterwards,so much more exciting...if my partner is "not so fellatio" talented,...i would try 2 show her,how it feels..

One of my ATF  loved to suck my cock and rub her clit on my body while I FF her.
 When the time came we would both O and wet her bed and ourselves.  
a very wet and enjoyable experience.

I want my BJ to be sensual, varied and delivered with attitude.  

For me specifically, I like the tactile sensation around the head, so wet and sloppy doesn't do it for me. I like varied pace, I like to start and stop... I like BLS, Also like some pressure on the perineum. Also, I don't like my penis to be the entire focus.  If there is a body rub involved, I like some slight teasing. Some girls I tell to tease, think that means a HJ...

There's a lot of technique involved in delivering BJS's that other's can comment on better, and of course attitude is super important.. everyone wants to feel wanted, and a good BJ attitude conveys that.

So glad dry bj was cleared up quickly. Hydration is key! Thats why I always insist on my client drinking water before he gives me a BBBJ. Going Slow and taking your time in a sensual way instead of rushing into trying to swallow the whole damn thing is so important. Let the build up to deep throating happen gradually so you don't gag yourself out of a good long cock sucking. Keep it interesting and change it up and don't over exert yourself right away - save that hard and fast pumping for the end! EOM

I've mentioned before that my ex was the queen of BJ's. I don't think there's anyone better.

I love cock in my mouth. Now that I'm knocked up, I sometimes prefer it over fs. It gets me super wet. Like wet dripping onto my thighs juicy.  

Best BBBJ I ever had was a bait and switch by the local agency.  Sweet little early 20 something.  She went down on that thing and I swear to God she could wrap her tongue around my cock with it balls deep in her mouth.  She didn't even bring a condom for sex and I asked her how she got away with that (we were at my home so I had one and she decided to give it up) and she said "It usually doesn't get that far" and I believe her.  What talent!!  BTW I finished with a nice CIM.

I had a repeat session with a lovely woman yesterday who knows what she's doing and loves having my dick in her mouth.  She has the cutest look of concentration on her face as she's sliding all the way down to the base, stops, sucks and then looks like into my eyes with this devilish gleam.

I should clarify don't spit on me! I don't really care if you spit in the sink after, but some ladies spit as lube and I really don't like to be spit on.

Regardless of the specific routine or moves, it has to be natural. Way less fun if it's mechanical/scripted

paramount to one's enjoyment on the receiving end.  
Also, the eye contact, slippery slide wetness, and the playfulness
which I instill makes for a superb oral encounter!
It makes me instantly hot!