TER General Board

Re: Private Message vs. Public Discussion
Mia Domore See my TER Reviews 1128 reads
posted

He wasn't trying to hurt you and he self deleted.
I am sorry you are so upset, but unless he is your lawyer, clergyman or doctor he is under legal obligation to keep the email you sent him private.  Once you hit send it belongs to him.

I'm curious what others think about the use of a private message of a personal nature, being quoted in a public forum.
Maybe I am being too sensitive, but at this point, it's not really about the content of my private message to Mathesar, it's about the principle of it being used publically...without my permission.

BoneWolf1535 reads

A private message is just that : private.

It ought never to be quoted without the express consent of your correspondent.

Under my primary name, i conduct a fair amount of PM.  I always assume that they have the same understanding as me, and will not use anything in a PM on any Board w/o permission.  Fortunately, I'm so damned dull, no one would care anyway.

If a PM correspondent used  some PM content on a board without your permission, he did wrong you.  But, unless it's of a sensitive or embarrassing nature, it's not the end of the world.

Letthe other person know how you feel, and that's probably the end of it.

The link leads to "message self deleted".  Guess he read your post and got the point.

As I said in my original post, it was not so much  about the content of the private message he quoted, the damage had already been done. It was the principle of the matter! Why let something so important and potentially damaging go without discussion?  Think about the things you have written to others via private message or private email.  I'm sure we all have written things not meant for others to see, yet we are all vulnerable unless there is a system in place here on TER that deals with something like what happened to me.  Hopefully, anytime someone uses quotation marks in their public post, the moderators here will catch it before it can be posted publicly.

"Hopefully, anytime someone uses quotation marks in their public post, the moderators here will catch it before it can be posted publicly."

That's not practical; that would mean putting everyone under moderation, creating a lot of unnecessary work for the moderators and slowing down the system to death.

The burden of preserving the privacy of private conversations lie with the correspondents, not with the system.  All we can ask the system is to protect the database so it cannot be hacked into, or leaked out.

In the end, if you can't trust someone not to repeat something private, then don't say it.  I and others certainly will become more careful in our PMs, after what happened to you.

- MS

Sorry this happened to you.  I did follow your link and it looks like the offendor tried to clean up the mess.
 Until I saw your post I hadn't really thought of PM as more than an email.  A couple of times I have written in them that I Wanted the contents kept between us.
 My dad used to say to never put anything in writing that you didn't want on the front page of the newspaper.  There are some mean spirited people out there (just look at some of the hurtful things written about people on craigs list) so ultimately you need to protect yourself).
 Maybe the materials for new members ought to mention the privateness of PMs.
Hope things are better for you now.
B

Thank you very much for your thoughts and well wishes.  I felt the need to bring this subject to the attention of the discussion board, because as you said, many people are naive (including myself) to believe that what is written privately, will remain private.  I think it's the responsibility of the TER staff to make sure direct quotes from a private email never make it to a public forum, and if they do, punish the perpetrator accordingly.  As for  my situation, I received something of an apology from him, but he also defended himself by saying it was "not a PM". IMO, anything sent to an email account, no matter where it is, should be considered to be a private message... especially if one needs a password to access the message!

He wasn't trying to hurt you and he self deleted.
I am sorry you are so upset, but unless he is your lawyer, clergyman or doctor he is under legal obligation to keep the email you sent him private.  Once you hit send it belongs to him.

Register Now!