So.. assuming donation and availability for the 8/10, 10/8 or 9/9 were about the same, which one would you go for?

... I just received an E-Mail from a fellow Hobbyist asking about the looks of a Provider I had seen wanting to know about her looks since he is contemplating seeing her.  We had both seen another Provider who I rated a 10 but he said while the services were great his pleasure was tempered because he didn't think she was that good looking though I'm not the only one to rate this particular Provider a 10.  

or Mr. Johnson won't want to play.
That said, the difference between an 8 and a 10 for looks OR performance on TER is completely arbitrary.

and by that I mean the whole package...both physically and attitude based on all my research. The numerical scores you've listed are all irrelevant IMO because there is very little difference between them and are based someone else's opinion.  

Very subjective. I suspect I'm more generous with looks ratings as a 64 year old Monger than is my cool 28 year old photographer Nephew. But the difference in my 8 - 10 performance ratings is noteworthy I assure you.

... it depends.  Suppose the 9/9's max score is 9 based on her profile, but what she does do she does very, very well. Then I might favor the 9/9.  

for most older guys, service trumps looks.  When you're on the north side of 50, there are very few 30-year-old providers that don't look pretty good.  

It is so subjective and inconsistent (numerous guys with different preferences and values are using the same system) that it can be at best a useful but unreliable rating.  Case in point: a while back a new provider seemed to take everyone by storm, getting 9s and some 10s, etc and it turned out to be a sham (and maybe also a bit of a scam) among others that were even phonier at the time.  I was originally attracted because some of the high raters were veteran players, and I didn't think they would play games.  Well, I'm not sure what happened but the air went out of that balloon very quickly -- were the guys seduced by expectations of an Oriental goddess?  Well, I doubt it but it seemed phony to me and I stayed away.  The goddess faded away quickly and has not returned.  

Not sure what your #'s mean. LOL

I like my escorts hot and young.  I can understand that many of the dudes here are old and just thrilled if a woman gets nekkid with them, and that earns a 10 in performance in their books.  But not in mine.

I'd say you need to up your game a bit, Walt.  Maybe lose the attitude also.  Then you might get better than "OK" sex from those hot, young escorts you like.    

wtf is walt doing here if that's how he feels?  oh, right, it's an alias, so i believe everything he says about getting all the hotties for free. yessir, walt, you da man!

experience, yes...some of us have been pleasing men longer than some of the youngin's have been alive

photos. If the reviews don't mention "accurate photos" then that is what I go by.

there is a LOT to be said for experience.  From my discussions with providers, the only thing they like about young, inexperienced guys is that they finish fast.  If a provider is horny and not just in money-making mode, she will opt for the experienced guy. She gets her O AND the dough.