I almost feel that by TER's guidelines if you fuck and get a BJ you are almost stuck at an 8 minimum and there are way to many other factors to consider besides what acts she did. Friendly, attitude, acting abilities etc...

My first ever review got kicked back because my score was too high for services offered.  I read the rules, and went from there.

So for me, I start at 5 and give a point for enthusiasm, kissing, bbbj, cim and anal. In reverse, I would subtract for rushing, mechanical, upselling to FS.

Looks are really subjective. IMO, anything 7 or over should be seen as attractive to all..my 10 could be your 8.

Just my thoughts...

for FS that was just terrible.  Generally it's all about the attitude.  

On the other hand, I've been with a girl that only have me a BJ and a HJ, but I still gave her an alias 9.  She's full service, but that night there was a different vibe, and while she was an amazing companion, we only ended up with oral.  I had a great time time, and didn't see any reason to rate her lower because in my opinion, her performance (inclusive of her attitude) was outstanding even though I never once put on a hat.

As for high scores invalidating a review, that's BS.  The review is the commentary.  What invalidates a review (IMHO) is to give a number and write two incoherent sentences that give no clue as to how you arrived at your 4, 5 or 10

I don't write reviews anymore...no need to.  

Honestly, the back channel method is all that I care about.  Way too many reviews are as phony as those 5 Big O's you fellas write about.

So I look at an ad in the mall...like the pics...and ask my pals who has seen her.  And then I get the real story..not Harlequin Romance novels written by lovelorn johns.

Hasn't been an issue for some time now.

Try it...you'll thank me.

And just an FYI...don't write the damn review with anything less than 8's....or you'll likely be getting emails from the hooker and her WK's.

A review is what you make it... You guys know better what you think is valid and what is not and who is a good time and who isn't even worth the effort. I mean, it's your money that you worked for, you should make sure it's spent getting the experience you want. A review is only an guideline, an artist's rendition, of what could actually happen. Some will like it and think it's a masterpiece while others will think it's garbage. I don't think you should let other guys skew your ideas for scoring, only the two of you know what really happened so if she rocked your world then so be it. No it is not necessary to write a review for every lady you see and no you shouldn't be coerced to change a score higher or lower. Do what you feel; the hobby is a very selfish sport so indulge and be happy!

I don't care about the numerical score.  The verbiage basically says it all.  If the Top providers all look marginally hot but not like 10s, and none of them do anal, where is the 10 coming from?

If a guy gives a 10 and I can't find a reason in the review why he gave her a 10, I will conclude whatever it is that the verbiage warrants as a score.

That's why I don't give any credence to scores, and, by default, the Top lists.