I guess it depends on your circumstancs....
I can certainly understand why the married guys do incall...no explanation needed. And I'd would never consider paying for BOTH a hotel room AND a "session"...probably because here in NYC / Manhattan, you are pretty much talking about an additonal $150 minimum.
For myself, I have read so many bad reviews about the conditions for incall locations, I would be very hesitant. I just don't care for flith or disarry. Given that I'd already be a tad nervous, that would just be too much.
I also like a tad bit of "romance" or "sophistication" with my session. I have read reviews of guys going to incall agencys, walking past other guys, going into empty rooms with just an old mattress on the floor, weird smells, etc. Nope, not for me, no way. I'd NEVER do an incall agency, or even an incall independent if I had read in a review that she "shared the appartment with a couple other girls", or anything like that.
I knew from my very start in this hobby for pretty much the reasons you cite that outcall AT MY PLACE was the way to go. "My Place, MY Space", as I have stated in more than one reviews. Everyone who has ever come to my apartment, pro or civilian, has always been impressed (really, it isn't ALL THAT great a place...just nice, but in NYC, a decent apartment is a RARE thing...). I have a view, also REALLY rare in NYC (usually you just have a view of anotehr building...even my $5800/month furnished apartment that I was in for two months when a first arrived had a view of the building across the street...and nothing else). Like you mention, I can play the music of my choice, pour a little wine, make sure I have condoms and Astroglide handy, etc. Basically, I have ALOT more control over things in MY SPACE, and thus MY comfort level is much higher.
In regard to the safety concerns mentioned, I'd agree...you should proably not bring a "streetwalker" or anyone who gives that kinda vibe back to your place. I've only seen mid level independents who were well reviewed, and girls from well known agencies, also usually with at least one review. Even then, I always hide my wallet, and have the "fee" already prepared. I *DO* own expensive jewelery (a Swiss Watch collection), but that really isn't the sort of thing a girl would go looking for, and I keep it locked away as well.
I suppose a "cash and dash" is still a risk, but for me, I've only paid up front twice (in my experience the better independents just need to see the envelope in an obvious place...they know asking for money up front sends a bad vibe), so I don't worry much about that. Plus, she'd have to get past me (I'm a big guy), get to the elevator, wait on it, and then get past my doorman, who I would have called from my apartment before even running into the hall. My guess is that any girl who came in with "cash and dash" plans would probably be discouraged once they encountered these things on the way in (first the lobby, then the doorman, then the elevator, and then ME once I greeted them at my door).
Having said all that *I* would encourage you to go ahead with your outcall plans, since you feel comfortable about the girl and you are looking to enhance the experience...
I guess I should also admit that I DID do incall once...with a provider who ONLY did incall, and whose apartment was so luxurious that IT gets reviewed as well...LOL!!!! (really, check my review for "Crystal" in Dallas, then look at all the other reviews...EVERY GUY mentions her apartment). I pobably wouldn't have done it otherwise...
-- Modified on 7/3/2002 3:35:34 AM