Ha! Another example of "beauty is in the eye of the beholder".


Sharon Stone over Jennifer Lopez??????
and Jessica Alba a 8???

I want to visit your country.

"BTW i stand by the 10s i've given. regrettably one of my 9s should have been a 10. but it is an imperfect world."

Logic me this..Unless I am a cat, how can I have more than one lifetime.I look at my ten's as being  one in a lifetime. In order to have another "One in a lifetime" 10, my first ten would have to drop down in rankings to somewhere below ten .There is only one winner.  
Thats just me . We all look at life differently.
If its any consolation,anytime a hobbyist has more than one ten,I automatically drop them all to 9s.

Here is my score,
Beyonce, Charlize Theron, Ashley Judd, Sophia Loren, Sharon Stone  10
Cameron Diaz, Jennifer Lopez, Kelly Underwood, Julia Roberts             9
Diana Ross, Jessica Alba, Terry Hatcher, Shakira                                8
Jessica Parker, Demi More, Anne Hathaway                                       7

Alba -10
Charlize and sophia at 30-35 Shakira for her moves and hips - 9
Ashley ,Julia ,Cameron , Demi 8.5
Sharon -7
Jessica Parker gets a 7 for her legs but the rest she can leave at home
The rest I could live without the rest of my life without a problem

Who is Anne Hathaway?Diana Ross has to be 72 yrs old wtf?? ok kelly not even a little bit she does zero for me .As does lopez her ass needs its own zip code I would commit suicide if i woke up with that ass her husband does not get lost in there?  It has to be double the size of my mom's  kendall

i would not score the ladies you've seen the way you have at all. to my mind your appearance scoring is all about pretty and not about beauty. "pretty" is generic but "beauty" is individual and has more character. i score appearance on beauty.

the only 10s you have that i think are deserving of it are Sharon Stone (maybe 9.5 would be better) but certainly Sophia Loren. i would consider Shakira a 10.

the rest on your list are all 9s except Jessica Parker who i will agree is an 8.

BTW i stand by the 10s i've given. regrettably one of my 9s should have been a 10. but it is an imperfect world.

Folks forget about current age compare at their peak beauty
Btw I forgot Aishwarya Rai 10

Anne Hathaway was in The Devil Wears Prada, The Princess Diaries, and most importantly Havoc where she shows the goods, and also routinely stars in my dreams.

Definitely a 10 for me, along with Jessica Alba.

If this were Spinal Tap I'd give Anne an 11.

Posted By: amazonian

Alba -10
Charlize and sophia at 30-35 Shakira for her moves and hips - 9
Ashley ,Julia ,Cameron , Demi 8.5
Sharon -7
Jessica Parker gets a 7 for her legs but the rest she can leave at home
The rest I could live without the rest of my life without a problem

Who is Anne Hathaway?Diana Ross has to be 72 yrs old wtf?? ok kelly not even a little bit she does zero for me .As does lopez her ass needs its own zip code I would commit suicide if i woke up with that ass her husband does not get lost in there?  It has to be double the size of my mom's  kendall

Posted By: Foreign-Boy

Here is my score,
Beyonce, Charlize Theron, Ashley Judd, Sophia Loren, Sharon Stone  10
Cameron Diaz, Jennifer Lopez, Kelly Underwood, Julia Roberts             9
Diana Ross, Jessica Alba, Terry Hatcher, Shakira                                8
Jessica Parker, Demi More, Anne Hathaway                                       7

Are Sophia Loren and Sharon Stone

And that's on performance.

just maybe, 10 -

your 9s are Sophia Loren in her prime and Terry Hatcher a few years back

your "maybe" 10 is Jessica Alba

But the one I would most like to fuck, is Ashley Judd, an 8-8.5 but I like her 'vibe'.

The rest of them I'm not interested in but I do credit that others might find them attractive.


I have spent many hours with shipmates, watching the girls go by (and catching some of them lol)

It is AMAZING how variable opinions on female beauty are.

I salute you my friend for your high standards and I congratulate all the providers you have scored 8 and higher on your reviews which looks to be most of them, especially the 5 or so who scored 10. With those in reach who needs Ashley Judd...and they should be looking into an acting career.... We all know looks is the main thing next is to be able to accommodate....Well done....

we have different definitions of "once in a lifetime". i understand yours and i don't use your definition because it would lead to never using 10. does the "once in a lifetime" refer to one's experience i"in the hobby" or "in civy life"? that's where we differ.

my civy dating life is complete, so there is a definite once in a lifetime standard there. there was a 10. the hobby facilitates having encounters with ladies that would be "once in a lifetime" in the ciby world.

that said, i don't care for the numbers much. they are so subjective that putting much stock in them is just silly. it is clear that i am a tougher rater than the OP, most of his 10s i would disagree with.

so it is not about being a cat and having 9 lives, it is about applying a scale based on the general population (my interpretation) to this little world where different rules apply.

on your interpretation of once in a lifetime one could also argue that a 10 could only be given out AFTER you're dead.

as far as my reviews, some have rated the same ladies lower, some higher.

However I take a certain attitude toward women - I look for what is beautiful, what may be appreciated, and not for what I can criticize....

With respect to reviews, if a lady does not need the review, and I do not feel the need to report a problem or issue,  I rarely write the review unless I can give her good appearance marks.....

And I will stack my "10"s up against any of the ladies in your list.

And while I believe that every one of my "10s" deserves the "score:, I truly wish I could have given a 12 or better to two truly exceptional and breathtaking women - my second and my next to the last "10"s.

Cheers

GTM

hell yeah!! she is one hot piece of ass.  gotta figure she is a tiger in bed .  just wonder why she married someone as thugly as Jay Z

I'd only rate two of your girls as "10s":

10s:  Sophia Loren, Sharon Stone
9s:  none
8s:  Charlize Theron, Ashley Judd, Jessica Alba, Terry Hatcher, Shakira
7s:  Beyonce (although her face is a "10"), Cameron Diaz, Jennifer Lopez, Carrie Underwood, Julia Roberts, Sara Jessica Parker, Demi Moore, Anne Hathaway (face is a "9")
6s:  Diana Ross (although if she sang to me i'd bump her to an 8)

Mama Mia. Viva La Pasta I agree.......
Do not Count out Aishawara Rai, she is probably the most beautiful of all.

When you list people like Sophia Loren, Demi Moore, and Sharon Stone, are you talking about how they look now, or how they looked in their prime?

Have you seen Stone on L&O/SVU? She looks good, but there's no hiding the fact that she's in her 50s.

There is a pic of Sophia Loren circa 1950s in which she is topless. In that photo she displays a truly spectacular pair of natural breasts.  

As for me, I'd take Shakira and Ashley Judd for their "vibe" as someone else said.  I can do without the rest.

You folks in D.C. ar so lucky. I see you have 3/11 scored 10. For me, after seeing 30 reviewing 14 have not scored any one  10 yet. Yet others have, the same providers. So i guess it is not just the look everyone is scoring to my standards. it is influenced by the experience. Yet I like to distinguish between the two scores, and keep in mind how people score going forward.
And yes they are subjective and should be so...That is the beauty of the world we live in...different tastes and different ideas.

With makeup: Beyonce 9, Charlize 9, Ashley 7.5, Sophia 8, Sharon now 8, Cameron 6, J-lo 9, Carrie Underwood 9, Julia 6, Diana Ross 6, Jessica Alba 9, Terri 6, Shakira 9, Jessica Parker 3, Demi 8, Anne 6.

Diana has bug eyes but looks good for her age, Cameron Diaz is had a pretty Joker face/sometimes I think she's creepy looking, Julia Roberts isn't bad looking but isn't pretty to me.

I'd  give Beyonce a 6.5 w/o makeup....most of these women look awesome with makeup on...so yeah I rate how they look to me with their war paint.  Jessica Parker is ugly as hell excuse my language with or w/o makeup...she looks like a bird. Looking at how some people rate it's amazing what some people find hot or attractive lol

-- Modified on 9/3/2010 1:10:40 AM