On what I am in the mood for. If I just want k9,rcg, just a  wham bam thank you ma'am, provider 2. If gfe, I need a pretty good looking face, so provider 1

Enthusiasm rules.  If your partner is not enthusiastic during the proceedings, what's the point?  Certainly, all of us would like both, although I'll take a woman who has a few flaws but wants to be there - everytime.

I think attractive people are not always what the media defines as attractive. There's something hot about a person's energy sometimes, I dunno that savoir faire

(The ability to say or do the right or graceful thing.) I also love fun or funny people, fast talkers, esp from the East Coast, Eyes, hair, smile, legs...and scent...so stereo typical.

The ones I can connect with during the session.  Having a pretty face or hard body are certainly major factors, but it's the ladies I connect with, and who are genuine, that will get a return visit.  

If I were only going to see her once... toss-up, game day decision.

I would see both depending on circumstances.

Gals with bodies of all shapes, sizes and degrees of firmness can be very sexy depending on how they use them, which, of course, is mainly a matter of attitude - the real X factor in all of this.

That said, I think a woman's eyes and smile are the strongest visual cues that lead me to feel attracted to her.  I find that shining eyes and a "come-hither" grin will make any woman's face attractive.