TER General Board

Dumb quote in a review.
Waterclone 78 Reviews 3890 reads
posted

I just saw the following quote in a review...

" I gave her a 7 only because I prefer darker skin, but that is just a personal thing. "

This seems dumb to me on two levels.

1.  Just because you prefer darker skin doesn't make her any less attractive.  You can be an objective judge.  I could prefer blonds, but still recognize that a brunette is a 10.

2.  She's got pics.  If you like em darker, why go to her and then lower her score because she looks like her pics?

Sorry for the rant.  This just jumped out at me.

-- Modified on 1/23/2004 2:40:33 PM


well, i might as well defend this poor dumb schmuck (the reviewer that is) since i myself prefer brunettes and when scoring blondes (a relatively rare occassion) my personal preference is subconsciously factored in (sorry blondes!)

from what i've seen of the many hundreds of reviews on TER it is IMPOSSIBLE to have reviewers be objective (go against their own instict or preferences) ... so just give up, it ain't gonna happen

I don't expect all reviews (or any) to be objective.  But that's usually on a subconscious level.  My issue is with the reviewer knowing it on a conscious level, and still scoring her lower because of his own issues.

I can't blame someone who thinks she is unattractive.

I can blame someone who thinks she is attractive but scores her lower, specifically because he isn't a redhead (or whatever).

chip24075 reads

this could also be interpreted as he was raising the score as he preferred darker skin, but since you had the whole review, you are probably correct. A link to the review would be helpful.

Beauty is a personal matter some of us like them tall, others prefer short, some like fat other like skinny, some like big tits , others like just a handful, and some like light skin and others like dark.
The beauty score is a personal judgement as is the performance score. Some guys like lots of teeth on a BBBJ others prefer gums, some guys like screamers others love it when girls pass out when they cum.
Let's just accept that we can't be all things to all people.

fasteddie513870 reads

Stating that his score is influenced by the shade of the providers skin in no different that stating that his score would be different if she had bigger boobs or a smaller butt... as long as it's scored as part of the "appearance" rating and not the "performance" side of the rating, it's a valid point.  

And because someone prefers darker skin DOES make her less attractive, to HIM... When pornstar Brianna Banks was known as Mirage and had "B" cups, I didn't give her a second glance, but after she got implants and changed her name... Yowzah!  I can't get enough of her videos...

As to why he chose to see her after viewing her photos, often the photos are Photoshopped and don't offer a true representation of the provider's true looks...



I agree with waterclone.  He had a picture available.  To me this seem like odering a seven-up and then thinking, boy, that wasn't very good rootbeer.  

I guess he should a had a V8.



The guy simply gave a seven and explained why (he prefers darker skin).  

That is the truth and I can appreciate and respect that.  Beauty is totally subjective.

You think it's dumb, which is also OK - you are allowed your opinion.  I don't blame anyone for telling the truth.  In this case, I don't think it's a dumb remark either.

I suspect you and the reviewer simply have different tastes and tactics.  Is this by chance a review of a provider that you care about?
Peace.
Silk

The way it's worded, he thinks she is better than a 7, but gave her a 7 because he prefers a different color skin.  That's what I find bothersome.  He admits she should be rated higher and that it's his hangup.  

And, no, I never met the provider and have no attachment to her whatsoever.

When the same provider gets looks ratings that range from 3 or 4 to 8 or 9, I question the validity/usefulness of the looks ratings in general.

FearlessLeader4318 reads

...the sentence is immediate and there is no appeal!!

Exactly why I ignore number ratings and look at the pics.  You're 10 might be a 7 to me, and my 10 might be a 7 to you.

Register Now!