I was glad to see this poll.  To me it's meaningful because it seems to be an effort to improve this site from great to even greater.  I too, am one of the 50% that go straight to "search reviews" and have often thought there were far too many clicks to get there (ok ok it's not like digging ditches but it's still improveable).

Here are the steps that it takes for me to accomplish a search inside TER (absent the browser plugin that I use when not on the Mac).

1. go to www.theeroticreview.com (bookmarked) 2 clicks
2. "agree"  - 1 click
3. Login - 1 click + password + click
  (suggestion: enter phone # & click search)
4. Reviews - 1 click
5. Search Reviews - 1 Click and
6. Scroll down to phone # field, scroll up or down to click search.

My suggestion would be to place a search box on the homepage (between step 3 & 4) that does a telephone # search.  I'm assuming the Tel # is the top search criteria based on the plug in using it (no programmer would not have investigated that one).  

That's 8 clicks versus 6 clicks.  That's 25% better!  Better for us.  Better for the server (less page views).  Better for bandwidth utilization and maybe a few more.

Is TER doing UI analysis?