it's from a member that you've never heard of and  
it's his first review ... how much weight do you put  
on the review?

It depends on who the review is about.  
If this persons first review is about a lady who had 4's & 5's and the new reviewer has doled out 9's & 10's , I would not believe them at all.

That's the magic word. Everyone is at their best for the first review (hopefully)
But can she continue with the 9/9s? Give her a couple of months...

For me to consider seeing any girl in this business they have to have at least seven reviews with five reviewers who have seen more than four girls. I will send a pm asking about how the girl compared to someone else they saw who I know. What I do have an issue with is a girl who has two reviews by two guys who only saw her who charges a grand an hour. If a provider recommends a girl I run to see that girl because no girl is going to pass you off to someone who isn't going to be good.  

It is just one piece of intel. I would combine it with other sources before I would make a decision. Is she on a verification site? Does she have reviews on other sites? If there is no other intel, then you have to decide what your risk tolerance is.

i wait until a girl has reviews from reviewers who have reviewed more than 1 lady.  the deeper the field, both on reviewers seen many providers and providers having many reviewers, the more legit in my mind.

neither one of them have any credibility.  TER used to refuse First Reviews by First Time Reviewers.  I thought it was a good plan because fake firsts are hard to sort but later reviews not so much.  I'd not consider her until she had a few reviews & at least some by experienced reviewers.

I would think that someone over there in tulip land was either drinking or sleeping on the job.

Is what I always say.

sometime we present situations that we already have one answer for, but are willing to hear other's thoughts.  

but mostly how I see it, but I found these helpful ...

but it is against TER rules to mention them by name or to provide a link to their site/s

...does reject a review for this reason the explanation given to the reviewer starts with: from time to time... This leaves the impression that it's a random thing rather than a hard rule.  

a "has anyone seen her" query AND a link to her reviews or website. I'm sure this can slip thru the cracks. Speaking of cracks, this babe had the "gap" (earlier thread) big time ... 😋

but in all seriousness, you will NEVER see a link to a provider's reviews on any site other than TER on this board. It is one of the rules ALWAYS enforced here and anyone who posts such a link is almost sure to be moderated for doing so.

The consensus already seems to be that the review is worthless. Which is pretty much my take of opinions on the internet, where ever they mabe found.

I have seen a few ladies with as few as 4 reviews (I checked swear it was 3 for both at the time) and both where fantastic. In one case I knew she had recently moved from an agency and had multiple dozens of reviews under another name, the other was the fantastic review and some other insider information. (PM's reviewer)

A lady does not want a review written about her? I found an ad on P411 for a lady that did not want me to write a review about her, because she said that she was low volume provider. Yes I took a chance contacting her because she had no reviews on her on any web sites. But in this case she turn out to be an awesome lady to be with. Even got a extra 1.5 hours off the clock, so I paid her for a hour but got 2.5 hours from her. A great time with her so I am happy that I took a chance with her. I already have another appointment set-up with her.  

But a girl has to start somewhere! The quality of the session is often male inspired.  Guys, go with your A game and sweep her off her feet so to speak!! We can have some mad skills but the chemistry and desire to please and be pleased is all about you

Yes, providers have to start somewhere, that somewhere isn't going to be with me, unless someone introduces her to me that I trust.

Truth.