I've heard those stories before.  If that guy used CL, he should have expected what he got.  Oh well, live and learn.

He gives her a 3 and 5 but says he saw her twice??

What was this guy thinking?  Oh, wait.  He wasn't.  Shame on you.

First off, if she was that bad, why go back?  And secondly, what's with that name?  Sounds like some kind of misanthrope who's on the wrong board if you ask me.  The old adage rings true...you get what you pay for.  

I think bad reviews are fair if they're true, but if you're doing it just to hate on people then there's a problem.  True, ladies should keep pics current, and if you're upselling and not providing the type of experience you advertise, then you'll get what you deserve.  

XO,
Stella