TER General Board

A question about weddings
IMI2ME 6 Reviews 4666 reads
posted

This question should probably be asked of Miss Manners, however, she doesn't answer on the internet (I don't think).

A friend has asked that I "give her away".  She is getting married soon, and has no family to so, and, much to my surprise, asked if I would be the one to walk her down the aisle.  Of course I could not refuse, and feel extremely honored.

My questions is, what would be the proper response when the minister says "who gives this woman....?".  

I thought "Her friends and I?", but putting the "I" in there seems presumptuous, or am I overthinking this thing?  

The wedding will be very casual, with only a couple dozen or so attending.  Your suggestions are appreciated.

Laura, I understood what you meant, and I appreciate Dionisios'input. Megapig, it's too late, I've been married 20 years, but, as Dionisios said, I'm not the one getting married.

Thanks Carrie, good suggestion, she was the first one I asked, and she said she'd think about it.



-- Modified on 9/16/2003 9:25:16 AM

It has been decided we will use "We who love her" - thank you, "Luv_Women" for your input.

Ahasuerus, she is a "traditional" woman, and neither her independence nor femininity are threatened by asking someone she loves to "give her away", but thanks for your input.

-- Modified on 9/18/2003 6:18:11 AM

megapig3982 reads


Don't ever get married!!!!

If you ever get that urge, find a woman that already hates you and buy her a house!

Carrie of London2190 reads

Why not ask your friend - the bride - what she thinks would be an appropriate thing for you to say?

Ahasuerus2148 reads

Just be careful in that case where in the ceremony you voice that response--very careful!

Who is giving the groom away, by the way?  Or is treatment as a chattel reserved exclusively for the female of the species?

-- Modified on 9/17/2003 2:29:19 PM

It's good advice.  Besides, she's the only one who read your post cafefully enough to figure out that it's NOT you who's getting married.

I will say that there's nothing presumptuous about the "I".  After all she wants you to do this.  You're right to feel honored.  I certainly would.

Dionisios,

I take offense to what you said. I read the post and replied truthfully. If the bride said she wanted him, specifically, to give her away, then when the officiator asks who does, he should then reply, "I do."

I recently watched the series "Race to the Altar".  The mother and father of the woman that won did not want a wedding with dancing and alcohol so they went on the show to win the wedding they wanted.  When they did win, her parents did not attend because of this.  The groom's father walked the bride up the aisle, and when asked who gives her away he said "We who love her".  I thought this was one of the nicest way of putting it and could work for most any situation.

Just my two cents..

Register Now!