It seems to me that the "Favorites list" as well as "Massage Parlor Girls" should appear on the "Reviews" page, rather than in the VIP area.  After all, they are all reviews.  If people are not logged in the VIP area, you can simply have the browser not display those links, have them marked as being inaccessible, or have them display an appropriate error message when you do try to access them without being logged in.

....while I don't need a list to remind me who my favorites are, I'd like to be able to use a list for possible future reference on gals I haven't seen but might be interested in for the future--however, I've never been able to make the feature work at all.  Am I the only one experiencing the problem?

This seems reasonable. I will talk about it with the rest of the staff members and see if we can come to a decsion on this.I will keep you posted.