Tarkenton shouldn't be there.  I'd substitute one of the above names (probably Luckman) and change the order some.

while Terry B had a great team around him, I have to give him the edge over Fran Tarkenton, who was an ofer in Super Bowls-Bradshaw was 4 for 4 and had a better arm-FT had a nice completion % but rarely threw the deep ball-and CY, any interview with Slingin' Sammy was a hoot and had more beeps than a long Morse Code message-He was the most profane man i've ever encountered-Great player and a terrific punter too-

Elway? Are you shittin me?????

Where is Kenny Stabler? Bradshaw? Dan Fouts?

I'd take Tarkenton over Favre anyday and twice on tuesday.

Tom Brady? Yeah Right!!!!!!!!!

And i thought i drank too much. Where is Tasha to hold me at a moment like this?

My boy Joe made the cut though i see.

Hey mrfisher? Nice to see a controlled demeanor on the board.

-- Modified on 2/11/2010 12:57:55 PM

The case against Y.A is that he had more career interceptions than touchdowns and never won a championship.

THOSE ARE TOP 5,  ENOUGH SAID,