Personally I think the poor man should stay at home.  He wants to win so bad but can't seem to pull it off.  He's past his prime and his arm is jacked.  

Like I said below I think he is trying to go out with a bang like Jerome Beatis did.  Win a superbowl then be done with it.  he just can't seem to get a team that is worth shit.

Should he go back, or should he stay home?

He already has won a Super Bowl.  The guy simply wants to upstage Green Bay.  Let it go Brett.  The more he continues down this path, the more respect he loses from the fans.

I was just saying he wants one more.  So he can go out with a bang.  Instead of just retiring.  I agree 100% with what you said though.  And the more he leaves and comes back he is losing respect from fans and everyone else.  It's kindof sad.  Poor guy.  Stick to the commercials.

Stay home tired of hearing about him

After last season's disaster with the Jets, he alone cannot get a team to the Bowl.  Now, if one of the top contenders this year has their QB go down for the season, maybe.  Otherwise, not worth the risk.  He seems to enjoy retiring, unretiring, then retiring again.  Time to for him to retire as a player, and maybe get into broadcasting as he awaits the call from Canton...

He is done, he needs to stay home and start his post football life.

He should stay home! I agree with ChiTownPimp, he is tarnishing his reputation with his annual diva act!

talk about him.

That being said I am glad he's not the Jests QB any more.

He can throw picks in a different uni this year.

I dunno...as a Bears fan, I'm amused at how mad the Packers fans are getting over his possible return to the division. Itz all good  lol

Hi,

I hope he goes to Minny!!!! That's one less team Da Bears would need to worry about next season!!!!

I agree DJ. Better that Favre go up there than say...Michael Vick.