And had my doubts about his attitude towards star player such as Harper. First of all, he benches him for not running hard enough. If there is any player in the clubhouse that needs to calm down a bit, that's Harper. So trying to send a message not just to Harper, or NATS, or their front office, but to the whole fan base and bigger MLB family that "new sheriff is in town" was a bit much IMHO.
The other side of the story, which didn't get much of a media spotlight was the fact that the had held a team meeting the day before outlining to the players the team philosophy that the players are to run first 90 feet real hard. No matter what. Harper broke the rule and got the punishment.
Just like you said, I was afraid that the whole clubhouse could turn on him and lose faith in him as the manager. But I am glad that didn't happen. It seems that the players have bought into his "tough love" approach. A totally different personality and a stark opposite of Davey Johnson's grandfather like figure that people have gotten used to for last 2-3 yrs. Given the fact that Matty's father was a Police Officer, it doesn't surprise me much.
As far as managing the game is concerned, he is doing a hell of a job managing the bullpen. He changed the closer from Soriano to Storen in last 2 weeks, and I applaud him for making that decision just at the right time.. Not when it was too late.
Mike Matheny, Brad Asumus, John Farrel, and now Matt Williams seems to be the new crop of rookie managers that inherited very good teams and didn't fuck it up.. We will see how Matty does next year in 2015.