If you're downtown, try out Taylor Shellfish, Walrus & Carpenter, or Elliott's Oyster House. Have fun!

The Brooklyn Seafood, Steak & Oyster House is my favourite by far with The Walrus and the Carpenter following, bon appetite!

While I have to agree that the Walrus and Carpenter is the most consistent place for oysters, The Salted Sea in Columbia City, if you want to venture south, is worth the trip.