Posted By: lester_prairie
Re: Technically parties are private entities
Political parties in the USA are just groups of citizens and aren't really parts of the government. So they don't have to hold primaries. They can pretty much do anything they want as far as nominating candidates -- defining slates of electors, etc.
Except that elections, including primary elections, are regulated by the states. Candidates must register as candidates and fulfill certain STATE requirements. E.g., many states require petitions signed by at least N number of citizens / voters to qualify. There are laws governing fund raising and election expense reporting. There might be candidate filing fees. And so on. I guess that there are fewer requirements if you want to campaign as a write-in candidate but if you want to be listed on the official ballots, you have to put in the effort and the big money.
.
Which brings me to the good old Smoke Filled Rooms. For decades, going back to the 1800s, candidates were chosen by politically powerful men getting together in smoke filled rooms to agree upon whom they wanted to run for office. There was wheeling and dealing and graft and corruption and selfish motivations. In 1968, Hubert Humphrey was chosen by Dem Party big wigs as the nominee even though he had not participated in any of the early primaries (Johnson hadn't dropped out yet). Activist Dems were pissed and primary rules started to change. In 1972, the Dems ended up with McGovern who lost to Nixon 49 states to 1 state. As 1976 approached, Carter had figured out the Dem primary system and carried out a strategic campaign for the popular votes in numerous state primaries and had the nomination locked up before the convention. He was not beholden to big wigs or power brokers. The Republicans also changed to a more citizen-based primary system. Keep in mind that those were the days of newspapers, radio, TV, billboards, and leafleting. No internet, no facebook, no twitter, no youtube, no PACs.
.
And here we are, today ... or even there we were, in 2016. I had posted to TER P&R back then about bringing back the smoke filled rooms. There is ZERO chance that Trump would have been a nominee in 2016 or ANY YEAR.
.
If Ye Olde Smoke Filled Room system was in place today, we would probably have BETTER candidates than the twitter - facebook - youtube crap has given us. I'm not sure who the Big Party power brokers would select, but it wouldn't be Trump or DeSantis or Vivek. They might still choose Biden except for the age thing. What we do know is that every candidate that was NOT selected would demand that we get rid of Ye NEW Olde Smoke Filled Room and go back to the facebook - twitter - youtube woo-the-popular vote system.
.
We, the USA, definitely needs a new and better system.
However it is shitty PR for a party to just screw over primary contenders. It illustrates what they really think about their own base of voters. Rubes too stupid to be allowed to have any influence on anything.
.
There was always a tension in the Dem party between the elite and the great unwashed that they claim to represent. They despise the smelly ignorant peons.
.
I have to say, the same is true for the establishment Republicans. They screw over their base every chance they get.