Don't know if I agree with that assessment, but I understand it. She is beautiful, funny and seems approachable. Like a girl next door.....
Michelle Pfeiffer - gorgeous face and exudes sexuality. Nice choice

I could not believe that either. So is no way in hell the hottest of all time. Grace Kelly easily beats that. Closer to my timeline I really think it is Tricia Helfer.

She doesn't get the recognition she deserves. I melt every time I see her

Yea Jennifer Aniston is hot, hottest no. How can you measure hottest, you might as well argue who is the beat quarterback.  We have some pretty hot woman here, at least as hot as Jennifer if not more so.  How about Sophia Loren, Grace Kelly, Ingrid Bergman, Raquel Welch, Natalie Wood and her sister, Lauren Bacall, Liz Taylor  just to name a few. This just shows the demographics of the Men Health.

Not my type, but Liz Taylor in her prime was classically beautiful..
Cyd Charise had legs to die for..
Catherine Zeta-Jones comes to mind..
Michelle definitely..

It's a toss-up:

Heather Locklear
Jessica Biel
Eva Longoria

Then there's the anti-list:

Kim
Khloe
Kourtney

Sophia Loren in her day was/is a classic. Charlize Theron is drop dead gorgeous and can act her ass off. But, for now, I'd have to go with Angelina Jolie. Sexy, charitable, smouldering, smart.......reminds me of Bailey!

I've barely thought Jennifer Anniston was even pretty until..

...Horrible Bosses so hottest women of all time WHAT?!  I can think of hotter like Monica Cruz (Penelope Cruz's sister), my lesbian lover in my head Kerry Washington, Paula Patton, etc

Shes gorgeous

I think Jennifer Aniston is way underated. She is such a natural beauty. I love her and I think she deserves it BUT I think J Lo is the most beautiful woman ever.

There are so many beautiful, sexy, intelligent women in the world that I can't choose just one to put on that pedistal. I mean, How about all the women just as hott as Jennifer Aniston that are not even famous? she is Very hott, beautiful, sexy, and intelligent but she is definately not in a class all by herself.

Can't pick just one.

There are far too many absolutely beautiful and hot women in the world, to pick just one. We have alot of very, very hot women here in Phoenix, they are just not famous world wide! As for Jennifer Aniston, it depends on the wether. Wether or not she rings my bell that day. LOL!

But then as hobbest aren't we inherently into sampling all the different favors of beauty and sexuality?  We can't decide thus why we are here in the first place.

...she's incredibly beautiful and sexy. Jennifer Aniston is really hot and she has exceptionally sexy legs but, for me, she doesn't inspire masturbatory fantasies as many others do.  

Cindy Crawford....then and now....

Amongst the living, some think:

Hedy Lamar, but then I always think smart is sexy.

My current favorite is Kelly Stables.

Jessica Alba has consistently never seemed to age...she always looks fantastic and she's a sweetheart!