Phoenix

Reviews
ki.wan 76 Reviews 1378 reads
posted

I found this interesting
So I contacted a lovely lady with high reviews to set up an appointment. She responded back that my reviews of ladies seemed "pretty critical" and she would agreed to meet me as long as I wouldn't review her.
I found this very confusing since I thought I was pretty fair in my reviews. I would appreciate it if some of you would read my reviews and let me know if you think I am too critical. I would especially appreciate ladies feedback. My reviews of Kristina Kennedy, Deanna, Madison Malone, Heidi and others seem to jive with most other reviewers. I think most of my low scores comes from BP girls who does not offer GFE experience and I should have known better than to dabble (I live in Flagstaff and sometimes the little head takes over)

Since you did not see her, you did not lose out. Do not second guess your reviews. They are yours. Maybe she does not want your honest review.

Peace

I have read a few of your reviews and you seem to be pretty darned fair to me.  While I have personal experience with only one of the lovely ladies you mentioned, I believe your review was 100% spot on.  You were fair and accurate with your description of her and her activities while being respectful of the person she is.  The only disagreement I have with you is that you scored her 10/10 and I would have scored her quite a bit higher.

riorunner965 reads

why I have chosen to review under an alias. One of the reasons anyway. So, I guess you have to make the decision as to whether you will be pressured into following the no review rule in order to see her. Good luck with that one. Personally, I'd probably just move on to a different lady myself.
   BTW... I've read some of your reviews, know some of the same ladies and agree that your comments are fair.
               Regards......RR

She must realize she doesn't compare to the ladies you gave good scores for

I would take it as a complement but also that she felt she wouldn't get a terrific score from an honest reviewer.  Keep reviewing the way YOU see it.  They are your reviews.  I've taken some heat for a review or two but you have to call it like it is.

ShillBill863 reads

Please pm my alias if you don't feel comfortable responding on the board. Thanks

If a lady ask to not be reviewed why is that a big deal ? I know some girls who like them , others don't, and others whom prefer to keep a low profile . Do you feel the need to review Every person you see ? Is it a sport ? Shouldn't there be some sort of reserve ? Like, flakes or robs and or an AMAZING time ? ( side bar.. where are those girls that you mentioned now ?)

 Also.. if you venture to a lower end provider and you pay a blow n go price and meet at a motel.. isn't what you got what you wanted ? Is it fair to review and be negative if you knew you wanted the serious you were about to get ? Shouldn't that be a given ?  

If the provider was reading your question after she asked you in private THEN ran to the board ... do you think she would still want to see you, ( or would any other provider ) would you still even want to see her ?

Sometimes we need to take a step back and think .

ShillBill739 reads

The Erotic REVIEW, was started so that hobbyists could share information about escorts. It's NOT the need to review every provider you see, but it is the OPTION to review. The ability for a hobbyists to make an "informed" decision can only come from reading reviews.  

Would you see a client that didn't allow you the opportunity to make an intelligent decision on whether you wanted to spend time with him.  

When a provider starts "shopping" for reviews than other hobbyists should know about it.  

I offer the OP props for coming to the board and posting. The exchange of information is important to both hobbyists and providers. There are RO and PO boards, that offer the opportunity to exchange amongst "ourselves" however, the OP wanted providers opinions as well.  

 

I've been around for awhile, and would have responded using my "real" handle, but cannot since I've already posted using my alias.  

Posted By: elitegray
If a lady ask to not be reviewed why is that a big deal ? I know some girls who like them , others don't, and others whom prefer to keep a low profile . Do you feel the need to review Every person you see ? Is it a sport ? Shouldn't there be some sort of reserve ? Like, flakes or robs and or an AMAZING time ? ( side bar.. where are those girls that you mentioned now ?)  
   
  Also.. if you venture to a lower end provider and you pay a blow n go price and meet at a motel.. isn't what you got what you wanted ? Is it fair to review and be negative if you knew you wanted the serious you were about to get ? Shouldn't that be a given ?  
   
 If the provider was reading your question after she asked you in private THEN ran to the board ... do you think she would still want to see you, ( or would any other provider ) would you still even want to see her ?  
   
 Sometimes we need to take a step back and think .

yaa I would have respond with my real handle but..................

Thanks gentlemen for your comments. I would still appreciate to hear back from some ladies on what they think. If you would rather PM me......

That posted here about seeing ladies etc emailed me and I didn't know it was him because he didn't identify himself until after a few emails. It honestly was weird but flattering to know he wanted an apt, as his online persona didn't seem too serious and after MANY post about the same thing.. I called him on it. He re-emailed me and asked why I didn't respond. ( One, he didn't give me correct info/two he didn't seem serious ) and I said he didn't seem like he was serious about an apt, and if he was I would be happy to meet with given the CORRECT info.. NEVER RESPONDED ?!  

Another gent emailed me whom is a known hobbyist on another site ( I'm sure he's on here too ) KNOWN for belittling woman, stalking, and playing mind games with them to get free apts. I at first refused the apt, but after his kind response of understand said ok. ( seemed different than what I heard ) After a few emails back and forth he decided he didn't like me after all..( or my rate?) and THEN called me a prostitute with no education and said he would flame me on the "mens"side..  

So please believe when a girl says or does something, its for a reason.
 
 I am  just like everyone else am selective in my meetings and want to make a connection-not a buck. So a persons online persona and or reviews do speak for you ( I have said it before). If this makes some people not want to see me, sorry.. I am not snobby just know what I am looking for and the type of cliental that works for me.

-- Modified on 5/16/2013 7:03:27 PM

Elite,  thank you for your view and response. It's good to hear what the other side has to say

providerincognito913 reads

She has certain standards (maybe all 9s or 10s?) and she thinks you may mess with her "perfection."  It's total bullshit and unfair to those of us who do not manipulate our reviews.  At least she didn't wait for your review to hit and then threaten you if you don't change it, but I wouldn't put that past anyone who plays these kind of games with their reviews.  

I would say don't see her, and I would also take it further and say warn other guys about her game.

Yes, I must post this as an alias because my views will not make me popular with my provider "friends."

Just my .02 I once gave a pretty negative review.  She tried to get it removed. It stands to this day. This actually happened at my house, so I was a little worried. I started getting the angry texts. Best thing to do....Do not respond. She eventually went away. Honestly the review was a little harsh. If I would have added YMMV at the end it would have been perfect.

ShillBill786 reads

Do you really think adding YMMV would have made it perfect? And the first time was actually at your house? Really? Oh right, you're the guy who posted about a b/s at The Studio.  

Nasty---- tried hard sucking my dick but nothing sensual about it. pussy was nothing to write home about. stuck it in her ass hard. i thought she was going to cry while i was slaming her ass. finaly stopped with no nut. she offered to suck it more but i just wanted her to leave. won't repeat unless i'm in the mood to make a girl cry while fucking her in the ass. i am not trying to be mean its just the

What ever the truth is the truth. Should I candy coat it? Would I write it differently today? Yes, but it is still the truth. We need to let each other no about poor quality girls. If you have the cash to play above my level so be it. That means my reviews are not geared towards you, but towards peeps in my income bracket. Have a wonderful day!!!!!

Posted By: ShillBill
Do you really think adding YMMV would have made it perfect? And the first time was actually at your house? Really? Oh right, you're the guy who posted about a b/s at The Studio.    
   
 Nasty---- tried hard sucking my dick but nothing sensual about it. pussy was nothing to write home about. stuck it in her ass hard. i thought she was going to cry while i was slaming her ass. finaly stopped with no nut. she offered to suck it more but i just wanted her to leave. won't repeat unless i'm in the mood to make a girl cry while fucking her in the ass. i am not trying to be mean its just the

Why, because I call it like I see it and I'm not scared to say what I think? The whole point of this website is to review prostitutes. If you have a bad experience you have to let other hobbyists know. Regardless, at the end of the day I don't have any problems with you. You have a problem with me, so that makes it your problem. I really don't want to get into these petty little battles on our regional board. Have a wonderful afternoon.

It's your typical 6-7 in looks/appearance provider shopping for easy prey hobbyist who like to give out 9 &10 reviews. She flirts with them on a board, then contacts them via PM, flirts some more until they set an appointment.

 She bats her eyes, sucks their cock, tells them how great they are, possibly gives them a discount then poof she gets a 9 or 10 in appearance in a review. I see it all the time, It's a work smarter not harder move by these ladies, it's the only way for them to compete with the true 9 &10 ladies in appearance.

It is a business and those ladies who are money hungry have multiple strategies to empty your wallet and get those high reviews, you either take the time and do your homework, or roll the dice and hope for the best

She was afraid that you'd give her the ratings that she deserved!  Fuck that!  Pass pass pass on that kind of shit.

This site is called "TE REVIEW" for a reason!  If they don't want reviews, fine.  But don't post looking for clients if you can't stand the scrutiny!

One of my "Eskimo Brothers" saved me a lot of time and money about a particular lady who posts ads - and so very hot pics - about once a week.  But she didn't have any reviews so when I asked him about her he gave me the intel I needed to make a decision to save my energy and see someone else.

In the event a provider and a hobbyist stipulate to no review, I don't feel a hobbyist should do a review. However, if the provider is a rip off artist, I think this should be reviewed. I don't mean that if the hobbyist don't like her personality or she don't allow him to make her cry by jamming her in her back side, that is BS. I don't think any provider should put up with that bullshit. I think the provider should black list the sick ass that wants to humiliate the provider. WTF, some one wants to assault someone and then write a bad review about her, that is wrong. Moreover, I think it is wrong that a provider can get bad reviews and change her handle and start all over. I try to consider the history of a hobbyist when a provider has some negative reviews. The reviews are important to me as a guideline, however not the only thing that will determine if I want to see the Lady. I usually will not elect to see someone that has no reviews. However, if I do,  I know it's at my own peril. I have been known to gamble...

Back the truck up. I have no interest in humiliating anybody. I have no interest in assaulting anybody. She advertised it. if she could not handle it she shouldn't advertise for it. I didn't mention she was 3 hrs late and brought her dog to my house. Quite frankly fuck you. You were not there. I hope you never have the experience I did, but if you do and don't review it honestly then your a joke.

Have a wonderful day!

Register Now!