Well besides what I want in a session.(I check reviews for that). My top 3 would probably be price, looks and age. I usually don't worry much about location. I will drive to any area of the valley to see a good provider. i live way out west anyway and only 1 or 2 in my area.

Top 3

I look for:
Hygiene
Height
Age

Yes, hygiene is a "had to be there" one, but still very important.

boog

1.Bigga Tits, That Go Booma! Booma! Booma!

2.Donation rate.
3. Location.

Have to be concious, of economics, these days. Hobby budjet is lower, so I have to pick spots.
Location. Don't like to drive a long ways. Ga$$

For me I would say the most important criteria are:

Appearance - I love short and petite, but most important for me is thin/athletic

Incall

Price - I have a certain price I will go to per hour, but not over.  I will also rarely schedule time with someone who does not offer better rates for 2+ hour sessions even if I am only booking and hour this time

Misty,

 I would have to say my top 3 are:

1. Reviewed
2. Outcall
3. Relative resemblance to photos on ads/website.

 Other than that, clearly there has to be an "appeal" criteria as well as a price point that is within my parameters - although I've dipped on both ends of that scale and found good providers and bad at both ends.
 What it is it you're looking for from your question, if I may ask?

JC

Killer looks and body are great but my top 3 are

1. Pretty face.
2. Attitude
3. Enthusiasm

I have meet some ladies in theirs 40's with "flaws" but they totally blew me away with the last two on the list. A couple of those sessions I was stumbling out the door on weak knees.

1.  Attitude is by far the number one but can be hard to judge reading reviews sometimes.  Does she seem to enjoy what she is doing?  Easy to talk to?  Does she try to get you in and out take her time... make sounds or do you need to check her breathing with a mirror? etc

2.  Location,  I don't often get large chunks of time so if I have a hour and a half window I cannot drive away from home to see someone then fight traffic trying to get home at a reasonable time.

3.  Price as long as it is not in lieu of performance so probably not too low unless she has great reviews consistently at that price point and not like one or two a day either LOL.

Attitude is super important.  I need to feel welcome.  I am older so I need to feel she is comfortable with me...
I have 2 cravings:  BBBJ and Massage.  I respond well $$$ if both are high quality.  I recently had prostate surgery and "willie" won't stand up anymore.  The lust is normal, the climax is normal but the provider has to be willing to work with my condition.  I'm scheduled to get a bionic dick in a few months but for now..... its limp willie....
As an aside...  I like to suck on nice ta ta's.....

...most mentioned it...Too young or too seasoned?

Also location...South Scottsdale to me is the best place I could be (freeway gets you right to me).

MsManae

i only see providers with looks of 9 or higher and performance of 8 or higher ~ that said dfk, daty and bbbj are a must for me....