The reviews for a lot of the providers will be wildly inconsistent...one review will say she looked like a model and did everything...the next review would say the opposite. My question is: Could the quality and quantity of the service provided depend on what the provider thinks of the customer (attractiveness, personality, etc.)?

(your milage may vary).  Remember, even though you are you are hoping to see a 9/10 looking woman and a 9/10 expererince, not every man sees a woman the same way, and a woman is not able to perform the same way every time.

As for your concern, I'm a simple man.  I currently weigh +/- 275, and once weighed 420.  Obviously, I'm no woman's dream, but have frequently found women, and have often believed them, who have treated me as the most special man in the world during my time with them.  I have rarely left unsatisfied.

jazz32

The true professionals will be able to provide excellent service to most any well groomed and respectful gentleman. Of course if she is attracted to you, that never hurts either.

The subjectivity of reviews comes up quite often around here, especially the ten point rating system. Though not a perfect system, it can be a mostly reliable source of information. I typically just use reviews to verify that a particular lady not a ripoff, bait and switch, etc. Beyond that much of your experience with her will depend on how the two of you communicate your desires and/or  expectations of the other, or can relate to one another. The enjoyment and/or satisfaction you receive is very dependant on the effort you put into finding the right date.

Often when you look at who else the reviewer has seen, you'll be more enlightened.  If the lady is super petite, a guy that likes a little meat won't see the same beauty as the other.  If it's his first review, she's likely prettier than his hand, not living up to his vivid imagination, or he's writing a fake review.  In any case, the single review is often suspect (in spite of the fact that we've all written a first before a second).  Performance ratings are more about expectations and clicking.  If you have swamp-ass, and she doesn't feel inclined to give you A+ service, the reviewer often takes that out in the review.  Reading the text, along with some of the reviewers other work often sheds a lot of light.  If you're still unsure, PM the writer of the review and ask.  I can explain every one of mine and we may just find that we like different things...

girls use.  Depending on what you like, you can be fooled easily.  I like them real thin.  Many girls pose certain ways to mask there faults.  I might do the same, but when the hobbyist sees them, they could feel disappointed, and I have.
But going back and looking at the pictures, I can see where I should have looked closer.  So study the pictures closley if you are picky like me.

I never figured it was a case of YMMV. More like "Your Client May Vary."

I use the Olympic system. Throw out the highest (the client who is also a friend), and the lowest (the Russian judge?) and consider the rest.

I would never hold a single bad review against someone. You just can't please everybody, no matter how hard you try. Neither would I place a lot of trust in a single good review.

I agree with you statement, and your method of selection, but the subject and first line of your post may be discouraging.

Honesty time, I just turned 42, and curently weigh 270,I once even weighed 420.  Needless to say, I'm not any young lady's dream date.  However, during my 18 years in the hobby, I have rarely met a provider who didn't treat ME as special.