In a smaller market what is the best way to find local providers that isn't BP. The selection when I search here is few. Unfortunately I don't often have the option of booking in advance to my goofy schedule so trying to get someone to travel on a moment's notice is difficult for same day.

You can check EROS and the verification sites, but BP is often the best or only option in small markets. Wherever you find her, do your research to increase your odds of having a good time.
 

You can try looking through your local Craigslist listings. Check the Gigs Section and the Casual Encounters Section. Also try posting an Ad yourself that you're looking to help a lady out in need. You'd be surprised at the responses you get

Seems like a good option as well. I noticed that the boards are updated a lot, though it may take time to sift through for your area.

...as "low rent".  

...in all the cities they cover, due to expense.

reviews means pass and find someone else.

That's part of the problem. The ones that advertise locally.... don't have many, if any reviews. I'm tired of TOFTT and putting myself at risk.