Well, first of all, imput is not a word. If you want my INPUT, I say why not write the reviews and score them as you see fit? Who cares what other reviewers think of you? If you keep hobbying there are going to be lots of good, bad and mediocre experiences.
I have found myself in a similar situation where I saw a provider that had mostly great reviews, but my time with her was absolutely horrible. Be sure the providers don't know your TER handle so they won't know who to retaliate against (just in case they lose their dignity over a mediocre review), and write honest reviews. I certainly will, though I'm going to wait another week to do it.
> Will people think im nuts?
No, people will think of you as an excellent reviewer and your reviews will carry weight.
After the hobby is fully legalized, you'll get your own review show on MTV. (j/k)
However, you will put yourself at risk (maybe) of scorn/retaliation from the ladies (see past few pages of Newbie board).
There used to discussion around a "point" system to have all review stike to a basic level of consistency. I think Admin has something they follow, but I do not know what it is.
Scoring looks is purly your choice, beauty is in the eye of the beholder. However, think about your answers, if she looks like her pictures and her pictures are current, remember YOU picked her out and YOU paid her, so a low score reflects equally bad on your judgement. Granted not all ladies are a 10 every time, but it would have to be a major bait and switch to have anything below a 7. In my humble opinion.
Performance is tricker. For instance, you may break a mythical review into the following categories as a way to balance your scores:
1) Blow Job Characteristics
2) DATY/Breast stimulation
3) Kissing
4) Single vs MSOG
5) Positon friendliness/variablity
6) Environment, Cleanliness, Odors,
Probably the most important variable of all you need to address is the overll attitude displayed in the session. Did the provider go out of her way to create/deliver your fantasy and appeared to have enjoyed your company or was she mechanical, bored, and more interested in her phone ringing and next appointment texting.
You may award "bonus" recognition for use of toys, exotic journeys, massage, and experiementation.
You may decide to provide "negative" scoring for lateness, upselling, absence of necessary supplies, unexpected partners showing up in the incall or at your door.
However, in my humble opinion, the two most important things you need to do on your reviews:
Be absolutely consistent, if you deviate from your "standard" know why. I guarrantee, it will usually be the attitude thing.
Remember, this is still a people business. You will at times meet a provider that does all the right thing, but the two of you just do not click. There is no chemistry, the looks are wrong for your fantasy of the moment, or one of you has a bad day. This is NOT grounds for a low scoring review. Be fair, especially if the lady still tried to make the fantasy happen. Not saying you give her a 10, but apply your "standard". It is okay to say in comments you did not click and most likely will not repeat, but a low score is just low brow behaviour.
Good luck with the hobby.