Interesting and good question! Anal is definite plus for me if I am in that mood but not a must for me (personal taste). I would say for me the single biggest factor is authenticity and enthusiasm- I have been with some good looking girls who are very professional about things and even if we do X or Y it is kind of mechanical so a little disappointing. And other girls (some very good looking, others attractive but not necessarily off the charts) who really get into it and clearly enjoy themselves and just love to fuck and I really connect with- by far the best experiences for me are those (and I go for something ongoing if good). I kind of go for the good girl with a naughty side type. So personally I look for things in the review that give me that feeling….

Right there with you.  My ATF is on extended hiatus and only saw favorites of hers but she thoroughly enjoyed Greek. I’d love to find an attractive property priced Asian lady for Greek. Asian anal is the unicorn of the industry

frankly I just look for consistency in the reviews.  I am a GFE person so knowing the provider is into GFE is key.  I know clients may have different views of what they expect but consistent descriptions of the persons performance is what I look for regardless of what specifically I desire.

I value the text of the reviews more than the numbers.  Obviously if a gal has an average of 5 For performance I won't book her, but I've been with many avg performance 7's that have been awesome.  I look at the iberall body of reviews too, not just the outliers.  Just because once she didn't click w someone once doesn't mean necessarily that we won't.  Why was the review bad?  If the text of the review says she was great and she got a 5, then WTF if everyone else rates her a 9 or 10?  Use judgement.  As for looks?  I don't book without seeing pics, and I pick the ladies I like based on performance and what I see, sometimes one man's 6 is another's 10.