Most if not all the ladies on your list have a history of reviews with similar scores..10s & 9s.  The reviewer you discredit sounds like a guy who makes his hobbying decisions based on what other gents have reported. In other words he ONLY sees the 10s  What would be absured if he saw these ladies whom everyone has scored highly and rated them a 7.  Now...if you can produce a bunch of reviews by him that gives babes a 10 that a dozen others rate a 7 then you might have a case.

I don't know all the ladies on your list but am quite familiar with 3 of them. My God man...have you ever met Dodda?  10? Hell...she's an 11 !

You take the "10" rating literally as TER writes it: "Once in a Lifetime."  So you've decided you can only give one 10 when you review.  I don't see it that way, and neither do most others.  For me, a 10 means she's so gorgeous and sexy that she can't be topped.  Equaled but not topped.
We all know one of the biggest flaws in the TER reviewing system is the numerical scores, and this issue isn't the only reason.  This one would be easy to fix if TER would just change the 10 rating to something other than "Once in a lifetime."  Still, I think you're being too literal.  What if you've already graded a gal at 10 and then see another who's just a gorgeous, or even better?
PS: I've been with CSJ a couple of times and she's a rock star who deserves 10s.  From the pictures of Doda Venett I'd say she's right up there, too.

Of course it's possible to have this happen. I wish I had the bank account to see all those 10s. I've only seen one on that list, but maybe in the next lifetime...

I'd say the majority of the women I've seen (my reviews are a fraction of those) are 10s. If you lined them up, I'd be hard-pressed to select one who consistently was superior, and I could make that selection only ex post. When I saw my first 10, Taylor Li from Philadelphia way back in the day, I never knew I'd meet Cara Saint James, one on your list I've both seen and reviewed. What's more, most of the reviewers who've seen the women I've seen agree with me: these women are predominantly 10s. I gravitate towards 10s, and I've been rewarded with extremely memorable times.

What bothers me is guys who rate women who are consistently 6s as 8s or 9s. Sure, taste is an individual thing, but if you're consistently the cheerleader outlier, one has to question whether you are adding useful information to the pot or something deceptive. After all, makeminemilf, haven't you encountered some women who should just retire?

If you're arguing about the term "once in a lifetime", perhaps we should go to the P&R board. The only things "once in a lifetime" are birth & death. When we're discussing extraordinary sessions with extraordinary women, I can only hope we are so lucky to enjoy as many 10s as possible.

Ratings are very subjective, maybe he has low standards, so anything 7 or better is a 10 to him.