If you narrow down your food preference and what types of plays you enjoy you'll have more concrete answers

But some of my favorites:

Food:   Shun Lee (Chinese);   Palm or Staghorn (Steaks); Grifone (Italian), Gari (Sushi)

Plays:  Kinky Boots, Dear Evan Hansen, Wicked, The Book of Mormon

Revival of My Fair Lady just opened at Lincoln Center. Fabulous, full of enregy, with new star Lauren Ambrose as Eliza.