Your idea of calling “prove it” when a young lady mentions she has pierced her nipples is so right on point.
During the winter of 2018-2019, while traveling and sitting in a bar I stuck up a convo with a group of 20 something girls obviously enjoying happy hour from their “boring” day jobs.
We hit it off and we’re just drinking and shooting the shit when one slipped her palm inside my shirt to rub my furry chest. That led to some unbuttoning of said shirt and comments on my hardening nipples.
All three copped some feels and out of the blue one asks me when I’m going to get my nipples pierced. I almost blew my drink in her face - damn far from something I would spend money on because I really like having my nipples locked, nibbled and sucked.
They didn’t bat an eye when the convo started getting a sexual twist.
So I asked the prettiest one if she enjoyed having her nipples worshipped - she surprised me telling me she really hasn’t been with someone who likes nipples that much. So I put her hand back inside my shirt and asked her to play with mine - I hammed it up a bit until she finally leaned in and began licking my nipple. Then she pulled away giggling because I was enjoying her tongue. I thanked her and complimented her style.
So I asked if I could worship her nipples to return the sensations-I didn’t really expect much more than giggles and laughs. Her friends dared her so she popped off her stool and led me to the restroom in the back bar area - being a wise ass I protested that I had a tally wacker so I couldn’t go in the girls room. She just pulled me in and slipped her blouse over her head showing this 60 yo guy a pair of beautiful “B” cup tits with the cutest nipples that unfortunately were pierced with little fucking bar fucking bells!!
Stopped me in my fucking tracks until her friends giggles brought me back into focus!! I commenced to love those nipples for all I was worth - I played with those boobies for all I was worth until I had them nice and hard. And best of all the girl was lightly panting and obviously enjoying my efforts. The piercings were a pain to work around until I had her nice and erect. Then they were tongue lick targets and I kept after her tits. Being an ass, I pulled and twisted them as I pulled off. I stepped back, asked her if she enjoyed my antics and much to my surprise she informed me that she’d just had an organism. Being a wise ass - I said prove it!
Before I knew it she’d put my hand down her pants to feel a sopping wet pussy!!
I pulled my hand out to lick her juices while looking her right in the eyes. I put her clothes back on her, tucked her blouse in and taking her hand asked her two friends if they would like to come up to my hotel room where we all can take a shower together before we explore the universe, cum until we are all drained and thoroughly enjoy each other.
Long story, not so short,there were four of us in the elevator and in no time at all the piercings were removed from her nipples and pussy.