Last year the top mentions (in no particular order) were:

Anastasia
Elizabeth
Kaylee
Samatha Good

Not Ms. Croft, but still blue-eyed and dangerous!!

http://www.theeroticreview.com/reviews/show.asp?id=89788
http://www.eros-minn.com/files/171295.htm
http://www.your-hilaryholiday.com/

Halle Moore arrived on the scene during 2011. I saw her ad on Eros but saw no reviews on TER. I asked about her on this board but at that point she was an unknown. I asked another provider about her also but at that point, Halle was also unknown to that provider. I exchanged a number of emails with Halle to try to learn of her menu but she was too cautious to provide any details. I finally bit the bullet and set an appointment. I'm sure glad that I did. Halle is a gem! I've seen her several times during 2011 and although I'm fully aware that I've been paying for that companionship, I can also say that we've become friends. I wish a happy and safe 2012 to Minnesota's #1, Halle Moore!

.....just looking at the video on her site is proof she has ultimate style.  However my idea of a fantasy provider is more natural, casual, everyday, stunning girl next door who likes to perform like in a serious workout.  So for me:

1. A nameless gem I met at a local club (sorry, don't hate me, can't provide more details)
2. The new Sasha/Sofia who I will review this week
3. Kaylee because her ass is so spectacular and she plays with enthusiasm
4. Nicole for her amazing oral talent
5. Ava, the best deal in town
6. Tiffany (when she is available), and the other Tiffany (Berkshire) when she offers her special

No question about it, in my opinion.

     She is SMOKING HOT!!   Plays safe, smart as whip, and pure as the driven snow. Although she has drifted a bit.  I would rob banks to see her.

She remains my ATF.

even-though, Portia and I haven't met, one has to be impressed with her number of reviews since July....

of Hilary that's not one of mine:

I have met Portia, multiple times, and she is fantastic.

I've known Ms. Holiday for a few years now. She is always a joy to see. For many reasons, and not just in the bedroom (where she is excellent, by the way). Hilary Holiday gets my vote for Provider of 2011. No contest. No one is better than she is. Thanks H!!

This ones easy. When I decided to hobby I was like a horny teenager looking at all the lovely ladies that I was going to meet. So I took the plunge and saw Ms.Hilary Holiday. It should really say how good she is that I keep scheduling with her over and over. I have yet to walk away thinking it wasn't amazing. She is so sweet and really makes the whole thing special from the set up to the session, she really goes the distance . That's my vote.

I think Elizabeth is second with 35 for the year

http://www.theeroticreview.com/reviews/show.asp?id=89788

http://www.theeroticreview.com/reviews/show.asp?id=143495

Celeste Leclair

http://www.theeroticreview.com/reviews/show.asp?id=176308

Hilary's #2 rating (for Minnesota) is richly deserved.

Hilary (seems to be a running consenus) and Wine you Wendy. Both have consistently rocked my world in the last year.

No one compares to Hilary. She is number 1 in Minneapolis, number 1 in Minnesota, and number 1 in the USA!

Halle is beautiful with a great pair, but not even close to Hilary Holiday for beauty, sexual responsiveness and genuine caring about satisfying her clients. Hilary is a true earth angel.

HH Has it ALL! Looks, Personality, Charm, Sense of Humor and Sexy!

Sheila Foxx by far for me.

Hilary is a beauty indeed, but I recommend a "Halle Experince" if you're interested in an awesome session!

"Doubles Provider of the year" for 2011 - what an amazing team!

A couple comments from my own review: "Two very different looking girls, each more gorgeous than the other in their own way," and "It turns out that the only things these two have in common that their generosity - and that they wear the exact same bra size."

http://www.theeroticreview.com/reviews/show.asp?id=187181

Lately, I keep thinking, "Would it spoil some vast eternal plan, if I were a wealthy man?" from Fiddler.

A happy and prosperous New Year to everyone!

My March 2011 review. So far, my only 10-10.

AGREED! Maybe of the decade!

I second that emotion!!  What a great time I had!!

I don't think this discussion can be had without mentioning Jillian. She arrived on the scene and shot to instant elite status and has stayed there. I've seen her twice and both times had an intensity that is very rare. And judging by her number of glowing reviews, I'm not the only guy who thinks so.

Jillian is a great pick too! A very sweet and talented woman.

Thank you for the compliments sweetie!!

Thank you so much for thinking of me!

Love 'em both.

She is sexy, sweet, passionate and caring....she's definitely one of my favorite doubles partners!
Im so glad she came on the scene this year!

Hilary

She is #1 on my list.
She provides a special time that goes beyond my expectatons.

I agree, Jillian is great!

Good question. Tyreffik makes a comparison maybe without tasting both delicious desserts.

Halle Moore last one i seen, before that Wine u Wendy, before that Hil Holiday, before that u get the drift u all are great.

+1 on Celeste!  Outstanding, to say the least!