Fear-mongering.
The only way the cell company could have precise location info is if you have geo-location turned on. And I have not heard of a federal law that requires geo-location information to be recorded by the cell company. LE can get it from your phone once they have it in possession. Or if you are using some app that monitors and records it, maybe. But I truly, seriously do not believe the cell company has it for every phone call made by every cell phone.
Geo-location requires internet access. If you keep data streaming and/or geo-location turned off in your phone, or if your burner is an old flip-phone like mine with no internet capability at all, then the closest they can come to locating you is by cell tower. Cell companies do have tower info and In urban areas they may be able to triangulate with precision down to 50 meters. That's a long, long way from 3 feet.
The suggestion that LE can ID you if the burner phone and personal phone are both turned on is equally frivolous for all the same reasons.
Assuming he had geo-location turned on, you still face the question whether any police department has the budget to initiate that kind of investigation because someone asked a question. Asking a question is not illegal. Even if it were, the crime we are talking about, at least in Minnesota, is a misdemeanor. Does anyone really think the Downers Grove PD is going to do the work to get location information just so they can call the Minneapolis PD and say "Hey, someone at a specific location asked a question that indicates he might at some unknown time in the future commit a misdemeanor somewhere in or near your jurisdiction."??? Get real.
The only thing correct in this post is that it probably wasn't LE. Best guess is tomthumb812 texted something the lady felt was indiscreet and this is how she blew him off.
None of this is to say we shouldn't all be careful. We should. But fear-mongering is not a productive way to encourage useful caution.
Posted By: CuriousSort
The cell companies know your location within 3 feet. Federal law requires the phone locations to be recorded.
So if you were sitting in your house or office when you made that call, and if it did go to the police, they have no problem at all identifying you. If you were not at home or work, but had your personal cell phone turned on and both phones have the same location coordinates at the same time -- they still know who you are.
Burner phones only offer protection if you never have your personal cell turned on at the same time and never call from a location such as work or home.
Being it was presumably out-of-state, you're probably okay though they certainly could let local LE know of your activities.
Be careful folks...
Though in this case I don't believe it was the police at all.
-- Modified on 11/4/2015 3:15:15 PM