Posted By: Burt2010
I said “gave to the world” not invented. The reason is there are too many debates over who invented what. The truth is when inventions are made there are usually several people who independently at approximately the same time invent something similar. Some fade into the dust bin of history while others go on to change the world.
Take the discovery of the Americas. People argue if the Vikings, Phoenicians, Chinese, etc. “discovered” the Americas. But it was Columbus who “gave the world” the knowledge of the Americas. It was his voyages that changed the world.
Who invented the computer depends to a large degree on the definition of what is a computer. It’s true that some consider the Z1 invented by Conrad Zuse (a German) to be the first computer. It’s also true that it was destroyed by allied bombers in WWII and did not lead to the computers in common usage today. (It was IBM, Apple, Microsoft—take your pick—that “gave to the world” the computers we use today.)
Paul Nipkow patented the scanning disk in 1884, but his invention didn’t lead to television as the world knows it. It was Philo Farmsworth (an American) and RCA that in 1927 “gave to the world” what we know as television. Henry Ford didn’t invent the piston engine, but he, more than anyone else, “gave to the world” automobiles as we know them today. He also “gave to the world” the assembly line and thus manufacturing as world knows it. Etc. Etc. Etc.
The point I was making above is that it is America—not Europe—that for the last century or more has lead the world in innovation, science and technology. In contrast Europe “gave the world” Facism, Nazism, Communism, two world wars and a colonial legacy (because of the way they drew lines on the map and failed to educate and train those in their colonial empires) is still creating problems today. Viet Nam, Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait, the Pakistan-India conflict, etc. are Europe’s legacy. As I said before, what happens in Europe today does not shape the world—the world’s “mover and shaker” for the past century has been America.
What Europe and Europeans do and think and teach is really of little or no consequence to the modern world. The world’s “mover and shaker” for the past century has been America. The future probably belongs to China and India, but Europe’s place is in the dust bin of history.
As I said above, America “gave to the world” airplanes, pharmaceutical, telephones, computers, the Internet, etc. I again challenge you to name me things of this magnitude that Europe “gave to the world.” I'm not talking about obscure acts that didn't change the course of history (such as the Z1 or the scanning disk). I'm talking about deeds of men such as the Wright brothers, Alexander Graham Bell, Bill Gates--men whose actions more than those of anyone else changed the world through things such as the airplane, telephone, and computer.
I repeat my challenge: name me three things of the magnitude of the airplane, telephone, and computer that Europe "gave to the world during" the past century. Face it, Europe is a "has been," not a "mover and shaker" like America.
-- Modified on 9/23/2010 10:23:49 AM
Basically what this is is you throwing out the things developed in Europe, picking out the point where they were beginning to be developed in the US, and then stating that they "gave it to the world". I can name countless things started in Europe, but your response will just be "Well, Europeans invented it, but it was really America who gave it to the world." You'll be able to say that about anything. You'd probably say that pizza, while Italian in origin, was really given to the world by America.
This is an argument of yours based off of your opinion, and not fact. You can do this easily because you're playing with words. You can repeat your challenge all you want, but I named three things that come from Europe that are in wide use today, and you simply come back with, "Well, it was invented in Europe, but that's not what I meant." For instance, X-rays were pioneered by the Germans. However, you're going to say "Well, the Germans invented it, but it was really America that 'gave it to the world'".
It's a ridiculous catch-all that you can use in any situation because it is simply your opinion. I'll prove my point. Here is a list of things invented in Europe. I want everyone to see how ridiculous you are as you claim that America was the real reason they were brought about:
Oh, by the way, your Congress in 2002 took the recognition for the telephone from Alexander Graham Bell and gave it to an Italian man named Antonio Meucci. But hey, America "gave it to the world" right? Oh, and Alexander Graham Bell was Scottish, by the way, even though he did get a US patent.
Europeans invented the thermometer, the wrist watch, the microscope, CDs (compact discs), video tapes, the newspaper, LCDs, the telescope, the piano, artificial refrigeration, launched the first submarine, trains, the lawn mower, the light bulb (I know your schools teach you it was Thomas Edison, but it was actually Heinrich Goebel, from Germany. Look it up.), the helicopter as well. So go on and dismiss ALL of those as being invented in Europe but being "given to the world" by Americans so people can finally see how ridiculous you really are.