I just saw a provider who had great reviews, looks were basically 8s and 9s, with one 6 and a few 7s. So I thought, no brainer. Well, I got there and was pretting fricking disappointed. She was at best a 5, at best! She was xtremely cool and nice, so im not going to name her, but wtf? Can we please be more accurate?  I know it may effect her biz, but the 9's r ridiculous. And no, beauty is not in the eyes of the beholder on this girl. So question, how can we b honest without hurting tge rep of the girl?

Talk about a no brainer.

It seems that a lot of people start at a seven, and go up or down from there. A 7 is pretty average, not hot, but not to a point that you feel you need to warn people about her looks. If you see several 7's you should consider her pretty average.

Unless you review her, you're just perpetuating the problem.

You're right.  Everyone else reports looks incorrectly except for you.

Unfortunately this is the case. A 5 should be average (i.e. "Plain") not 7. Someone who's average is neither noticeably attractive or unattractive.

I've run into the same problem as the OP several times (I go through with it because they're not ugly and I'm not an asshole) with tons of 8 and 9s when she's really a 6 or 7 at best. Nowadays, if I see any 6s (or even some 7s), it usually means the girl is not hot. You're right, beauty in the eye of the beholder is a bunch of nonsense; if someone was willing to rate that girl a 7, then she's can't be very hot. Girls that just consistently have 8-10s have always been quite attractive in my experience. Then again, I've seen a provider in the top 10 with literally nothing but 10s, and I thought she was an 8 (still very hot on my scale, but let's not put her on the Heidi Klum Victoria's secret model level--those are the reference 10s).

Not trying to attack you, but it's inflated ratings like yours that are misleading. In your last 6 reviews, you've given out five 10s. I've never seen any of these women personally, but from their pictures, I find it incredibly hard to believe that these women were PERFECT and MODEL MATERIAL. Could I see any of these women in a magazine? Would they fit right in on the runway of the Victoria's Secret Fashion Show? If not, then they are not a 10.

Obviously ones experience will cloud a rating, but let's be objective and stick to just the physical appearance.

And nothing else. Just because a provider advertises on here doesn't mean we all want to patronize her. Personally I couldn't get hard for a big girl regardless of what she did and she'd be rated low. Meanwhile, you might think she's gods gift and get a semi over her ad.
While I'm thinking about it, I wonder if ratings are used to gain favor or preference instead of their intended purpose. I've talked to other guys that think that some reviews seem like advertising and are "cookie cutter" when read.

Also, the Maryland board needs more minis.

Guess I ramble when I'm locked inside all day. Rock on ya'lll

Actually I have seen 2 of those women and his marks of 10 are very reasonable. I would give a 9 but the fact that he takes the time to write a review and gives an accurate review does not make him the problem. I review as well and I have only given out 8,9 ,10 for appearance. Why? I research carefully and only see girls that average at least an 8. Couple girls I thought were average in the face but there body made up for it.

I think your idea that 9,10 should be preserved for the Victoria secret catalog is whack. Even if  those girls opened the door when you knocked, trust me they wouldn't look like that. NO Girl looks like that that doesn't have a team of people working on them- hair stylist, makeup, perfect fit of clothes, lighting etc....

Actually, I always thought 1-10 was kind of ridiculous so I have come up with my own rating:

10- Model Material, A list Movie Star looks- ( Once in a lifetime is stupid). The model could be a Victoria Secret or JC Penny model but she still looks fantastic. Instant attraction  Sex comes to mind instantly but you know she is  SOMEONE YOU  COULD NEVER SLEEP WITH.

9- Extremely attractive- Think b list movie star, TV star. Someone that would definitely turn your head in public. Sex comes to mind pretty fast.  SOMEONE YOU ARE PRETTY CERTAIN YOU COULD NEVER SLEEP WITH

8- Attractive- The girl next door or at the office. You notice her when she is in the room. you are strongly attracted to her and think you have SOME CHANCE, ThOUGH REMOTE. of ever sleeping with her.

7- Average. Think this is someone that doesnt rock your world. Sex may or may not come to mind. YOU FEEL LIKE YOU HAVE A GOOD CHANCE OF HAVING SEX WITH HER if you feel like pursuing it. There may be times when other features (smart funny rich, mutual interest) could push her into the Attractive category

6- Below Average

5- Ugly


4,3,2,1= Shreck

i would assume and I am also guilty that some reviews are written soon after the session.  Your nuts still hurt, you still are in the JFG and you feel that you for that moment you fell in love with a goddess.  
Due to maybe misleading the troops I settle down for a few days, reflect then write.  Yeah some of my first impression 9's are well really 7's with a good smile.   Guys we need to get real on this and not look at it as a creative writing class.

that guy gave some ugly gals 8's and 9's as well.  One of the last girls he reviews had acne on her face and she was a 9! LOL.   CMON MAN

Obviously looks are subjective.  And, in the current rating system there is no way to grade personality other than to mention it inn the text.

I still contend that 7/9 can sometimes be the best combination because you usually get down to earth women who aren't full of themselves.  Not all the time and not all women.

And then there are the guys.  Some guys are just jerks who deserve crappy treatment and then take it out on the girls.

Life's not fair, go with the best info you can and don't blame someone else for your actions. (not directly intended for HDguy2)

-- Modified on 3/7/2013 12:11:03 PM

maybe he meant 7 is average of escorts.

not escorts.

a couple of the best looking are Catherine and Kylie from Canada.

....I was just a 5 in looks (O_O right?! lol). You can't really tell someone what is supposed to be hot to them and what's not.  I've very, very sexy to some guys and  THEN some would say I'd need to pay them to get f*cked by them lol it is what it is.  I don't think any of the guys who've given me an 7 or 8 in looks or the gent who gave me a 9 for looks should be called LIARS of all things or dishonest and then guy who gave me a 5 is more honest (or only honest one) or accurate then all of the others even though how I answer the door is all the same (I make sure I look good enough that I'd want to do me before I open the door).  I'll NEVER be an overall 9 to a guy who prefers stick-thin or blondes even my face for example is prettier .... i'm already at a loss and i've had guys "bright enough" to come to see me even though they knew they weren't particularly attracted to my type (but I guess that's something else).